Adaptation et cloud computing : un besoin dabstraction pour une gestion transverse

Transcription

1 Adaptation et cloud computing : un besoin dabstraction pour une gestion transverse Erwan Daubert To cite this version: Erwan Daubert. Adaptation et cloud computing : un besoin dabstraction pour une gestion transverse. Other [cs.oh]. INSA de Rennes, French. <NNT : 2013ISAR0010>. <tel > HAL Id: tel Submitted on 14 Nov 2013 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. Larchive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin e au d p t et la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi s ou non, manant des tablissements denseignement et de recherche fran ais ou trangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv s.

2

3

4 rts s rrs t 1 r sts r stts t t Prr t r st rrr P ss t st

5 t trr s st s r r s r q r tr tt t s t q rst st s r s tt q rtr tt 1t t ss tt ss r s trs r t r s r q s s23 s str r s ssss q s rt rs tr s tt rs s s srtt trs t rssts r rt ss r rrr s P3t q s s ts s t rr rs r s

6

7

8 s t rs s t rs þ þtrt þtrt Pr tq trt rst t þþ tt rt t1t t tt tt t s strt tt rt s rt rstqs strt r strr s s s strts r tt s s r 1s s rttrs r 1s r sts rttr rt r 1 t s strts r s sts qs s sts rs þrstrtr Ptr t strt r r 2t s

9 þ r s rt rstqs r s ts r Prs st Prs rr r t ss ts rq rt t1t s rrs t 1tst r t 1 t tt t t tt þþþ trt r 1ts r r t strt srt 1 t t rt rt t st tsr t t2 s rt rstqs r t2 ö rt s ös s rt rstqs s s t2s ös r s rt rstqs r ö rstrtr s rt rstqs r ö tr 1ts ss r s t2s ös t s2st s tt r t t P rt s2st 2t s t t st 1ts t rq Prt 1 rt þ tt s t þrstrtr s tstr Pr12 r rstrtr t t st ts r s s Prt 1 rt þ tt s t Ptr t tsts trs

10 s t rs stt sr rt rt t þt sr t þt sr tst r 1t tt 1 t2s t str t st ts r tt t1 Prt 1 rt þ tt s t t srr str t 2t s þ s s t Prsts s Prsts rt tr t1t st ts str s 1ts rs trs ts t tst s s rts rrs Prsts tr st t rt t strt Pts s tt t s r s rs st s rts

11

12 Pr r rt þtrt

13

14 þtrt rst2 r s s t rr t þtrt r ss P s tt r r s stqs r rt st s tr trs r st tr 2 t s t2 r sstt r2 s t sr tr t ts rst tr t tts sr s s rss t tr2 tt s rtq ttr r st t r str rtq t s s sr r rr s rssrs r tqs ss r srs t trr r tst t r s 2 s 2 s t rt tr s s r 1trst s rssrs rs s rssrs s s s s rss rs t r st s r 1 3 rst 3r s rs rttt tsr s rstrtrs t t 3 rst s srs ttrs s rs rst rts t2s sr rt s qs s q s tstrs t r rttr s t rs r t rsr s rts t2s srs t s ss rrsts tt rttr st ss Pþ tr Ptr þrstrtr r r þrstrtr þrstrtr s r þ tt r strt r rrt 1 rstrtrs ss þ st rs ss 2r s sts s2st s rts s rss s tr s s ss tstr s sts s s s st rs r 3 q rt 2r s s rts rss s Ptr Ptr s r P tt r s trt s s tr 1 t t tr 1 t t r t sr t s ss t ts st r st trt rstr tr t rt s tt s rtt t r s Pr s rs P 1stts s s tr q rt 2r s ts t q r s Pþs r sr trt rts ts ts q s ss s r

15

16 þtrt Pr tqs rss r tqs rr st r rts r rtr rtq ttr Pr 1 rstrtr rr s s rtst s s s rst stt t rr s t s srt s s rssrs s s rstr tr st ss r tq stq r tt r s tr rr srt t rt r r trsrt rt r1 srs tqs tt s 2t ss ts sr rstrtr st ss rr trs tt t tr s tqs t t ts r t 1 s tt s rts r tr rr ttqt s ts 1stts sr st ss s sts trs rs t tr s r tqs q t sr r s Pþ trs r tqs s tt r trsrs Pr r r t r 1 s stt rssrs t r t s s2st s tt st rt ts s rrr t s 1 t s2st q s tr s rrs rstrtr tr t s ss tt rstrtr tst s t s r rrr rt rt rr t srr Pr s trs 1 1 tst s t s q r st rrs s ss s tt s rts r sst Pr 1 tr t r tr r rstrtr r r s s rts r tsr s ss rrt rs r s rs t s 1 Pþ st st rr s Pr 1 Pþ r 3 s Pþs r st s s rs st s s t s q t r t q rt rt s rstrtrs s tsrs s ts t tr r s s rts 1 t tr r tr 1 q st t s trs t s rrts s 1 tt s t t s trs rs q tt rt tr r t trsrs t s s trs sst srs s tt rt tst r rt rtt t 1qt q st s s ts s s s trs s q r t srt r r r s t rr s s 1 trs st ssr sr tt r tq s s 1 st q s r s sr ssr rstrtr tr t t s s s t ts s r s1 tr s st trs tt s s2st rtq q rt ttr r st rttt r tr rstrtr t r t t ssrr tt rt t s rt s tstrs t s sst r trs tt

17 þtrt s sts tqs Pr 1 s s rs s q rs r s tsrs s s s s s ss s ts s ts rstrtr 3 t t s rr r tr tt rt t t st st tsr rstrtr r tr s tsrs st rq st ssr ssr strts r rrr sst rts sr s s 1 r trr rt s trs 1 s ss r rr s tts tr s 1 st r tq r s r tt t s t rr 1 r ssrs srs rt s s 1 Pþ r rttt r t rs srs t rsr r sr r s2st st r s s 1 Pþ rt tt ss rrr r rt rstrtr tr t s ts t s ss s rrs trt tt t s rs strt rttt rrrr tt tr s rts 1 s ss rttt rt tr s sts tqs tt strt srt ss srt t s sts q st r rstrtr tr s ts strt rr s rt rrst t rtr s2st þ s2st rrs s s rts 1 q 1stt s t t q s t rss rrs rt rttr s 1 r 1 rr stt s s rssrs t rs rstrtr s s rts 1 t tr t s rts ts rrsts 1 ts t r t r strt rt rttr r s s ss t s srr tt strt srt t s r rt tt t s s2st s tt t tsr tt strt r rsr s rrts t s rr ts srt rss r rt qs s2st s tt s ts tt strt r tst tt strt s rt rst r s s2st s tt rt rtt s s2st s rst sr rts tts rstrtrs tsrs ts qts s tt strt s tt strt st s s rts ts rttt s r s srs r sts 1 rts 1 s tt strt rt rr str s rts 1 s st ss sr strt s 1 r 1 r s rts st rts tr tt strt st strt r 1ts tr t rt trs rt rstqs t tr rtts s rr stt st ss tt 1tst q rt rr str t r t s

18 þtrt tts q st rstrtr tr t r ttt rr str s rt rstqs s qs s tts tt st ss rr str s s t r s t sr s rrts r s tr s rts tts tt strt st sr s ts t ts sss þ r r r s s þ r r t s rt r t s tr1 tr s s 1 t t t þ r t r tr r strts s s rr stt s rts s s2st t rttt rr s2st rt rtr s ts s rts s qt rs rtr 1 t s tqs t ts þ ts s rt rt s t s st ss r s s rr stt s2st t tr s ts sr s2st rs 1 t tt t s ts t 1stts 2s sttq r 1 tr s s ssrr r ts r r q rst rss r r t s r rr str s rts 1 t tt s ts t s tsrs t tt r s 1ts r 2 t rr s ts ssrs st s rts 1 t tt ssrs rr stt rstrtr t 1 rts tr s 1 s ts rtt tr ö q rr st tr 1 t s trs 1 t t tr þrstrtr s trs s rts rrst srs tsrs Ptr s trs ts s ös st s srts tt rsst s rts tt ssrs rrt r t þs rsst ss s ts rttt ssrr t s tts tt t 1 t s tts r ssrr q tt st t srtt rt s s ts t s s 1 t r rs ss s rr r t s sts s q ts t t r tr t s tts q st r rstrtr tr rst t t st rs st t r tr r st t1t s q ssrt s tr1 r st s s tt t s t1t r t ss rs s rtq ttr sst r s rs s s rts t2s q 1stt r t s q s rts t2s tstrs s s r s sts t t s ss q r st r s st s ss s t rt r 2q t sst ttrr

19 þtrt r rrr t ss rts ts s t1t r ss tt r q st rs t qst tt t t t tr rs t tr r st tt rt s rrs t s s rttt sr t tr s s2st s s t s rrs t s s r r rrt s rt rs rttt rr stt s rts ts t rt strt rttt rr tt r trsrs 1 rts ts tr r st ts strt r t tst s rs s 1 t r t t tt s2st s s tr s r s tr1 tt t s t t t r s tt strt r sr s2st tr r st s tr1 tt t s tr strt r r tt t1 sr s tr1 st r st s ss r 1ts r rttt sr s s ts rr t tt t st s q t rt tts 1stts t tt r tst rts rts ssrs st tr r st t tt strt trrs s ts rr r tt 2r trr t r t r s 1ts t rr ss r t st s s t rt srr t tr ts tst r s r rrt s q t sr tst r rr s t rt trr t tr strt rt rtr s tr s rts 1 tt rt tr s s2st s tts tr tt rt t tr t t t r st s rsts s tr1 r st s

20 1 rt tt rt

21

22 tr t1t tr r st s t s 1 s s sqs st rt s tr1 tt t s t r st s sss qst t t s rss sts 1stts trt rt t rst q t 2 trr st st r st tt rt rstq t s s2st s rtqs ts t t t rtq s s s sst rr s rssrs rtqs ss r srs r sqs tstr r q ts t st r s s s tt rt2 r r ss rtq ttr st st rs s s q t r t rs rt tt r r t tr st tr 1rt srt r s trq s q trt st rt s rs trs s ss trrs r s sq1 tstrs 1 þ s rs trs st s ttrs r s st s st þtrt t trt rrs 1 rssrs rtqs tr t st rtt r q rs s s rt 3 r rt þ t s q þ rt Pr st rss sts sr t ss r r 1 t t r t t rt r t st r q s ts t r s t r rrstr rs q r t s t r rs rs s rs rt ttr s rs r r þ 1st rts t2s r r s s s rrst s sts rs s r s rsttrs srs s sts st s st sss r t t tst s s tr r s

23

24 t r s rts t2s r tsr s 1 ts s s trs 1qt q s s r st rt tr trs tr r t s sts s q r t r s1 tr1 s rs t rrts tr s rts tr s rts t2s t tr t s r s s rss trsst t2 s2st rt Psrs rss 3 þ t rs t s trts sss t s r s ss s s r s st t rs s r trs ss tt r t tt r t r s trs q sst t strst s srs s srs t tr þrstrtr Ptr t t rs ts rrst st t s tt s s ss rs rt rstqs ts r1 q s srs srt rs s st ss s tt t r q rtr r st sr r rr sr s t tt r trt st t r s tstrs q st s srs rs s r q st tt qt rt t r s srs ssr tt q srs t r s s s ts r 1 sr st s sr s s tt t r rr ss s trs r s tr rssrs t ts

25 t1t trs 1 r 1 s r t s rt s srs rs tt r trt t r s rssrs q ttt s srs t ssrt r st s q r tt t rr s s tt t r s rss r s r tr s trs t s tstrs q st r t s srs st t s ssst 1 tstrs s r t s srs tsr s rs ss st t r 2sq s s2st rr sst st s s sr s srs r r rs ss t rr s s st s sts tqs q st s r s 1 srs r s r 1 st r r r st s rssrs q st r s st s rr t s ts s 1 srs st st s rr t s ts q t t r t t t tt st stt stt sst r tr srr 2qt s rssrs t s ss t r rst t 1qt s q s r s2st rtq str trrs s t str r ss q sr s s2st r str s r s t s rssrs ssrs t tt stt q tt t r 1 s q rs rs s s tst s rs srs r s srt s ts s rt q r trrs s r 1 t ssst rts tstrs rrt s r 1 srs rs r trrs q t r t st sr s rs st rt tr r s tstrs t s t sr s srs s ss tr r s rt s tsr s srs t r 2qt r r s rssrs rtqs ts s rr 1 s ss r s rt s tr s ts ts s srst s rssrs rt tr s rts s q rrt tr s ssst s rssrs tt t sst r tr s t s r rts strts tts trrss stt r sr r st r r t q t rr rt sr s strs t r 1 s trrs t q s s s r tstrs ssr t q r tst 3 srtr tt t r ss r tt str s s rstrtrs r st stt r r 3 s s r s st stts s r t rs ss r t srs r s Pr 1 st s rr t s ts ts q stt s srs ts t s srs ssts st r s srs tr r s srs rstrtr t rssr st st ss tr s tt t s st s r s tr t rssr q s t rsst t r sqs s sts rr s sts rt st tt s

26 tt tt s t s s þ st qt q st rrss str rrst st 1t s s2st s s s t s trs tt t t rr s s2st s rtqs tt qs ts stts r s trsst s s tr s s s2st s t s s trt s t qr r s rtts s r r t r s trts s s2st s tt s s rtts t 1s t s str s rr s tsr t s tr t s ss sr s s2st s t rt t s r r rt r r r s ss s t r tt 1t t tt tt s s t trt tt 2q st r 1 t t t rt s q s1 t þ 1st rts t2s ts tt s r t sr tt tr t r tt r trq q srs r trs tt r 1 t s t tt t rt qt rr t tt r tr ss r tt r s rtt r 1 rt t tr s r t tr r rs tt rtt sst r rtt tt r 1 tr tt tt tt rt rt r rt 1 t tt r 1 rr tt tr P r tr 2ss P 1t st s trt rs r r2 rt t ss q rs t s2st tt þ trt s tt tr str tt q st r srr tt t ss rts tr r tq rrst P

27 t1t s r t tt q s sr s tt t s tt 2 st s qtr ss r r r r st srt q sst srr t1t t ttr s ts q sstrt tt t1t t r s rssrs ss r s2st sst rssrs sq1 r rs s tstrs sst r s rr t s s rt t t rsq s srt tt s ts t s st 2s s st r 2sr s ts q st rs t r t s ts s tt st s t s q s strt tt s st 2 trs s qst t tt s st r sr strt tt s r s 2s ts trs ts trs sst st t rtt r q rt ssr tt rt s2st tt st st r r s 1 t q s r qr s ts s r t P st rs P ttr rt s sss rttt s ss r 1 rts ssrs s tt s P rt t t 1trt qtr rr t s tt s rr stt s rts ss q t r sr tt trt r s q s q s2st t tr r t sr s rttr t s rts s tr 1 t t s rt tr rt s q s q s2st t tr stqr t r sr r tr tt ttst t3 s q s q s2st t tr tr ss rssrs r tsr s tt trtt rtt s q s q s2st t ttr t s rt r s ttqs t s 1t rrs tt st st ss r r 1 s2st st t r 1 s ss t rsr t r sr r s rr stt r r 1 r 1 t s trs trst q rrs t r ssrr s st tt t q rt r rr stt s2st trss q rrs t r s r s r ttt s r t 1 t rt s2st s2st r 1 rt 1 1 q st s2st q st rs 1 t t s rr stt ss t s 1 1 st st s q s q t sr s2st rs 1 t tr t s rr stt t rst st 1 sts trs s r 1 r 1 strtr rt srr t r t st rs trs tt s t trts tr s tt s

28 tt s s s s ts rrs ss ss t ss rs st t ss ts t rrs ss t r s r t r r st r rr tt ts r t r 1 rtt rt r 1 t rr 2t ss s ts rs 1 t t t trtr rts s r s srrr rt s sts rt st tt 2q s s2s t s s t tst P r t s2st tt s t s s2st r 1 s s t s trs t rttt trr ss s2st tr t s srt t trss rt s t s tt t tr ts s sr s2st r rrr s st t s sts tt rrt tt t s rsss rr st r P rs q rrt s s sr s t t 1 t t q srt qr rt

29 t1t tt t s strt rt t t r q q 1st rts t2s tt s 1 rt tr rs t r r t t r t sr s2st t r t r t sr s trs s s s tts rstrtr tr t st s ts rts t t s tt s s tts t sr s2st t t t t r s s qs sr s trs Pr 1 st ss q rstrtr sss tr ss rssrs Pr r rr s s tsrs rs 1 t sr tt rssr s s tsrs s srs srs ts t tr r s sr trs rssrs t t st s s t sr tt s ts t s tsrs t tt r t sr qt sr t r t tr s srs r s t s trs t r st rq st ssr r tt r tq trsrs r rr tt s 1 t sr tt tr srs 1 tr tt r tr s rts 1 1 ss t s st ss r r sst r q s s2st tt tr s s 1 t s q st s r s 2 qt s tqs tt t r 1 s s ts q s1 tt 1 st sst rr s s s2st s tt tr 1 st r 1 r s 1 tt s s2st s r s trs st tr s s s2st s tt r 1 q 1 ttt r r t tt t 1 s r s s st Pr tr t s s2st s tt st ssr r srt tt 1 rts 1 t s r s2st tt q t tsr s srts tt rts tr s 1 1r r rr ss t s tts t 1 þ srt t ss r rr srs s2st s t t sqs tsrt s s trs s s strt t s t r 1 s r t r r st s2st tt q s s2st s t t rt tr 1 t s tt s st r s rssrs srs r rssr rss sst r str tr ss s q r ssrr tt s ss s s trrs Pr t tr str rr srr ttr r t tr s ss s rs tt rt s rts ssrs s tt s st rs trrs strt s q q rrs r s ss rts st r strt q st ssr r s rssrs srs

30 tt t s strt s r rs sts r r r strt rrt tr ttr s s Pþs rs sr q t s s ts rstrtr tr t t rst s Pþ s st s qs rt s tstrs s t rt r t rt rt rs tr t t rt st ss ss r t srs s2st s tt t 1 r s s2st s q t s 1 srt ts s sts q s tt t st r 1 ss r strt r s s 1 rs s r t tt strt rrsrt s s s Pþs rs s r s 1 t st s r s2st tt srs s2st s tt tr rs t srt rs ssr tr strt s q r q st sts Pr 1 rt st s q r s rstrtr 2ts tr t t rr t rt tr st r s rstrtr stt tr r2 t t tt P st rq st ssr r strt t sr s r t rstqs t s s sts 1stts r t r s 1 q 1stt r rttr 1 s2st s tts s rr r srt t

31

32 tr tt rt r t tr s t s rr tt s2st r trsrs tr s 1 ssrr q tt st t rt Pr r r s s ss s tt sr r s rts 1 q t trr sr rstrtr tr t s ts s rttr rssrs r strr r s tqs tts t1t stt t s r sts s tr s rts sts q rst srt strt r t t tt s2st rtq t s rs 1 rt rstqs rqss r rttr st sr s ss r tsr tt strt srt t tr 1 s r tt Pr s sss st s rts rt rs ssrs r r stt strt Pr rrt s rts rt rs s r sts 1 s stt s rts rt rs q s s s t Ps s r sts st s sts rttt r s ts s r sts st s sts r s s2st s rs s s st r s2t s tr ttt q strt s rs ts 1stts r rrt s rr t s rqss r rr strt rssr sr s rt rstqs strt r s trr Pr r tr s2st s s 1 ts s s2st 1 st ssr ssr strt sr s s ts s r sts s tt st rt r rt rstqs ssrs r sr s ts t r tr tt sr

33 tt rt t1 r rr tt r tq trsrs tr s 1 s r r rr s s2st s tt s 1 r r s2st tt r s rts 1 st t st rq st ssr r rr str s s ts s tsrs t s rstrtrs sst rt s2st t st s st s ts s tsrs t s rstrtrs s st ss t s ts tsrs t rstrtrs st rq st ssr q s trt ss sr t rt q st 2sq rstrtr q r rt tr rt tr q r t ssr s rts rt s2st tt r sr s rts sts ts tr s rts tr s rts s rts tr tr s 2sqs rstrtr strt st rt t sr s r s1 s 2 sqs rts t s rs rts rt s2st r s s rt r s rt r s rrs tr1 s rts s t rt tr t r rtt s rts ts s2st s r tt t r 1 rr r 1 sts sr rt tr tr st sst t tr 1 r r rr t rt q st ssr r ss tt t strt r trr rt st rq st rtt q tt t strt st tr s rr stt t r t r q s sts ss t rts tt s rts trts 1 t tr t rstrtr t tr s s s s rts rt rstqs Pr 1 tr t tr s srs s rts 2t s2st 1tt rtr r 2r s ts s qs sr tr s Pr rstrtr s rts rt rs tqs rrst s rssrs t rs rts r q st ssr r rr str s rts strt trr rt st ss ssr r rr str tt t r t s st t t r t t s trr r 1 r sst r s s 2rs t s tts q st ss s rt s t s rtst rts 1tst tr t r rr str rts tts t r ts sr rs rt rstqs

34 s rt rstqs strt r strr s qs s s q strt s rtt t t rr st t tt ssr st rt r q s tts rsst s rt rstqs t s tt s q st r rstrtr tr s ss r s ts 1t s2rs s s t r t r st s s2st s tt st rt s sss s2s t s r 1s q rt strt rttt srr t r s2s t t s 1 t t s s2st s r 1s sst rt tr rr t s rr stt strt s t rr stt strt tr rtt t rr t rst Prtt t s2st 1 st s t t st r r sssrr t t t qr tr s tts rts s2st st rq s ss q strt q srt r 1 s2st t r r strt tr s2rs r rrt s2st rs 1 t r sr rt t qr sr s2st rs 1 t 1rss s rts rt rstqs s strt s rttrt sr r t t tt str t rttrt r s tts tt t s s 1 qs st s t rt s s tsr s rt rstqs s st tr rt rs t rt tst s strts r rr stt

35 tt rt s s s r1 s tts r tstr st stt r st t s t r ts rr ss ts sr st r ssrr 1 tstrs qt sr sst ss r tt r s rr st s rssrs Pr s ts st t r rt P q st rss tt qt sr t q st rrr s ts r tr r t s ts t t tst tqs s srr str sr t s q t r srr t s s s sts r s srt s s tt s ts rstrtr þ rt s s rts r tr t ss ss t tr t s rts tr s rts sts ts r s rts s rts sr 2sq rstrtr r tr t s sts r s tr s s rts t 1 q tr s s tr s r s s2st r q rstrtr ss tr t s rts rt s ts q st s trts tr s tt s t s ss r rt sr s tsrs Pr trr t t r t s s sr q rts s s sts srt r srt tt tr sr sqs s s1 tt tt s2st 1tt r tr s srts rs st ssr q strt q s tss st rr str tt s t r q str tr ss rrtt rr tt sr rt t t q s s 2sqs t rts sst r r s t tr s r rr str t r t s s ts ss rstrtr q tr t rr r 1t s2rs rt r rr s rts s2st s t t s1 tt sr rts 1 rstrtr t tr tt trrs strt t t qr s rrts s s tsr t 1 s st tr r r t s rt rstqs t s r t s rts strts 1stts

36 s strts r tt s strts r tt s strts 1stts r r tt ts t rt r rt s rts ts rs s s P t st s s sr r r 1 r st s s r 1s s trr trs s s ts t t r s rrs srts 1 t rr s t s tt t t r strtr st s s t r rst rt t st s s st r t rt t s s ör rttrs r 1s s r s s r 1s s s tr r t s s s P2t r t 2 s s s s s s ts t s tts rt rr stt rr t rt s t s tr sr s ts s s2st s tr ts t tts st trrs rts tts P t s tts r trr s s tqs rr stt t 1 t s ts rr st s ts r rts sss stts rt s tr 1 t rr t r 1 tt rtt t r s rr t t s s tr ts t tts tt rt q t t t rtt s2st rs 1 t rttt s ssr r s t q rrt tr s rrts rr s s r 1 rt r s tq q t tr tr s t rsst s ss tr s r1 sq st rr st r tt st s r 1 s s r t s tq rtr t r q t ss rsr s tq s rttrs r 1s r sts r tq st rttr s t t sts t st st r r r r s rs r s þr2 r t t r tst s sts s t r t ts r ss s sts t 2r sst s rs sts trt qs rtt rt s trs ts q st s sts s trs t rt s sts st s tt s s 2t t2 þs rsst t rq rt s tt s sss trrs trs s trs st r s t tr s rts sts t t rrs ss rtr sts t trs q rt

37 tt rt tr t r t t r tst s sts tt r r 1 tsrs 1 t t r 2r 2 qt 1 sts q st s tt s t r strr r r t s s rs sts t rt t ts s r s rttr t r srt ts ts r t t sst s rs sts t trs ss q st 2 strt t rtr sts t t s rr t s ts tt s st st t t qtr s qst t r s rts rt rstqs q s s s rtrt s t tt qtr s t rr st t t1 t t rt st s qs rr stt rs q s ts strt t t r t st s rsts s qs rt rst rr stt s2st s str s t 1 rt rstqs 1tst t r 1t s2s s rr stt s ss rsts r rt q s2st q s t t þ 1st rss rs s sts Pr s s s s r str r t rt r s rr stt t s rs 1stts rt t r tq tt r st s r rs rs r rsst s t s tt t rt st s sts s s ts t st t 1ts r r st st rs r þs rs t r rr rttr ts str s s s sts st s r s t2s t s sts s sts t tr s rs t rttr t 1 t t q st t r 1 t rttr s q str rt r tr r tr t rt rt s2st s q st st rrr rttr s2st tt s sts sts q s 1s tr s sts q r srt r tt 2q r s sst ts r rr str st s ts s ss s tsrs 1 t s ts t r s rstrtr r t q r s tsrs t st ss s tr 1 r srr s q s s s st s ss s r s s t s s tsrs rt s s r r rr stt s2st rttt s sts r s2st rt s s2rsr s2st rttr r rr tt t r t qr sr s2st Pr r r rs r rt t strt s ts

38 s strts r tt rt rt st sts srtt t sts trs sts st st r 1 ts r q 1s s ts tr st rrst 1 trs rqss rs r t q r ss s t s r 1t t q rrs tr st s sts s r s sts sts s s sts rt r r 1t s trts tr s sts trrs s ss s s ss s t s s tr s tt s rs r st t s tt s rqss r tr st st st ss 1t t r sst rtr st s tr srs sts sts rt rs srs tts tsrs rt sst r s ts rts s ts q s tsrs t rtt t r rt rs s q sr srs 1 q st rstr tr tr t t s s r sst r s sts sts st r s sts strts rtr ss sts s tr 1 st ss r srr t s s s st s ss r s tsrs rt t t r s st s s r st s rttt s sr s rts ts tt s r rt s tsrs sr rstrtr r s q r rt rs s st r tr r 1 s2s t trrt r rt r sst tr s rr r t s r tr rs s trs st 1ts rt rttt r s ts r rs s s ttrrs rr sr tt st s st t st r st st q s rr s s ss tr strt rttr rt r rrt rt srs t r s P3 2 r rsr s ts ss r srs q trsst tr 1 s srs s t ts tr st r qs t s s s s trs r s1 tr t st tss trrs r srt trrt r sts tr1 s srs st t st r q 1st q rs trt r r ss rt ss 1 srs tr tt ts s trs t s s1 tr s rstrt s rts srs rqs st s sss s s t sr q sr t trr t s r t rt s s t 2q sr s s rs srs rst rt q

39 tt rt rstr sr q sr srstr r s tt tt t st q sr sstt trt tr sr rst tt s q t tr rr sr rstr st rstr sr q rt rr tr s srs tr s tts rttrs rt s srs t s r st 1st trs s ts rs s s r t þ s s strts rt s ts rttt r tt s P P P st tt r sts rt sr s r tt q ss rt rt 1 q st tt sr s t t P st rr t r 1 t rttt sr t ts s s sr r srs tt tr st s sr s t t rt r s qt s s rt rstqs tr sr trs t srtt t r 2s P rt s sr srs 1 st t s st s sr tr t r st ss r srr t s s s st s ss r s tsrs rt s tt s tr1 r st s r rt st P rt s rr str t r s s2s t sq rr st t q s r tr q tt st t s srs 1 rr stt s r1s sr s stts t q rr st q tr rt s rr str srs tsrs t t r t s tsrs r t rttr st sts rttt t sr t t st sstrr s s tqs q t tr s s rrt s rrs t s rts ts s t qtr rts ts ss q t s sts t rs srs t t s st ss s r rr t rt ss r s rr t s ssrs tt s srs s s ttt t q t t rr t tsr sr st r s tts r 1 P srt r rttr s tst s rts s r t s rr t s ts s srs trs q rt r s 2s t t st tr ts s s ss t s tts s t r s s q t rt tt t tt st tt rtt tt ts t tt tr q tt s t r t rt rt t rt t q rs r

40 s strts r tt t sstrr s tsrs 1 t sqt s t r t s s 1q s s rt rs rtts tr strt s s s sqr s rt rstqs rt 1 t strt s rts ts s2st sq s rt rstqs t tt t strt t tr ts s r tr tt s st trs ss r srr s q s s s st s ss sr 1tt r strt t st s ss sr s tsrs 1 t rt rt st tt s s ts sr sts rt t tt st tt rsr tst str r t ts rt s srs tt rsst r rt s t s r tt 2q s ts s rt rstqs rt st rr tt s tr 1 t ss r t rt t r q rt t ss sr t q s tr 1 t rt ss t ts r t tr t q t s t s rt rt s rr str t rt t st s ss rr str tr 1 t ts q t r s rt rt s sr 1tt strt t tr t rt rr st rt rt 1 t rt 1t srs stts rttt 1 sts 1 s tsr 1 t r r r s s r r r s r tst strts t s s s r s rts ts rt tt q st tt tst t rt t s st t s tt s s st s st r r 2s t t s2st r ts st r st strst r r t t r s r r rttr s q rs sr t t tr 1 t Pþ r Ptr þt s Ps Pþ st trsr s s s q s rt rstqs tr 1 t st rss t st P r Ptr s rst tt s r r r r r rr s s rs st rr s rs st rts s tt t r t sr s t strt t rtr s strts t s ts

41

42 s strts r tt r tst 1 t Pr rs s t s tt rs t s r rtt 1 sts tt s q s t s trr s r tt rr st q s st s st st rt s sr s 1 st s 1 q rr st s st r s 1 t rs r 2 s tt r t t s rt rs tr trs r tst 1 s s rr rt r rt rt t st rt strtr 1 rt r rt r t 1 t t s ts tt rt sr rt t s s 1 s s t t s2st tt rrs t st r s trrt 1 rs r st s r t rt rt r t t t s tts tts q t s rr rt 1 t t trrt Pr rt r s2st tt tr tt r t t rt s sr s rts 1 sttt t 1t s s rr t s strt s2st s st ss sr srr s q s s t st ss rr s tts t s qr s st s ss sr strt s tt s rt r t rs sts 1 t sr s tsrs t rt t t rtrt st tsr r rt sts r rr s rrts s2st s rt s2st st r s ts rt rr stt s r ts s2st t tr s rts rs t q st s s ss r sts s sts rr stt s r1 rt r r r t s r t rt t st st s sts rr stt s s ts rts q rt rr rt t s2st tt s trt r s t srs sts r srs ts rt r sts s s2st q st st q s sr rt s2st t st tr rsss tt r r rt t qr t tt rs s s sr tr 1 t t t r s rstrtr 1 t rt s s sr strt s2st

43 tt rt s strts r s r sts s strts t srr srt r tr tt s rts 1 s strts t tr s Pþs s rttt rt tr s rts sr rt rt tt s s 1 t tr rt r trr rrr s sts qs st r t ts r r s sr tst s tqs s tt st qtr s st ts s r r rttr t s trts qt sr ss s tt t rt rqs sr tr 1 t t s s rssrs ss r tr 1 t r s rts s st s s rr str st t s ss tr 1 t t strt tt tr tr t s tr t r t t s ös q s Pr tt s s st s ts s r rr rtst sr rstrtr rttt s r t rstrtr t tr s st s s 1 r r tt st rt s tr r 1 s s2st s rr t t sr tr st s s s s st r rs s ts trsrts t t st rttt rr t 2r s ts trr P sr s t s s t t P sr s sts r s s rt tr q r s s s t s t P Pr r tt t st ss tsr s s rts s qt r s t rt tr P st s q t rs r s r r q t 2r rt rqs r tr r tt rt tr 1 t strt sr qt sr t st str 2qt sr s ös s t s s s ssrs q tt st st rtt rt rs s ts P t tt tr ts r s sr tr 1 t rt q t þ st ss st sr srr t s s s ss s tsrs q rrt s tt s rt t s sr tr s s ss t t r rst s t rt s tsrs s st q rt

44 s strts r t 2r s tsrs sr 3 sr rstrtr 2ts st st t t st rr t t s ts r t ts t tsrs s q r r t ssrt tr rt rtt t r ts t s ts t t tr Pr s r ts Pþ s q rs strt r rt r Pþs t sr s rstrtrs ts q 3 s t rs rt tt st rst t t rt tt q t tr t s 1tt s rts q st st ssr rr t str s s ssrs r 1 t t s rt rst s s rts st t s rssr t s r þ st ss s r rttr t r s2st 1tt rqs tt st rt tt q r srt s s rts s q r rr s rt s s rr tr s r rrr s trr P P q st ss rt r tr r s s ts r r s tsrs s qs t s ss t Pr P rt rr tr 2 t s srs s qs ts q s ss s s srrs 1st s srs rt 1 tstrs rr t rs ts srrs rs sts sr st t r t tt r P tr t ttsr st t r t s tr t tr P r ss srt r tr ss sr s s q sr s srs r tr r r s r s ts t r 2qt str t rrr rr tr t sstr s s t s srs t s ss rt tr t str t r tr r tr st rs r P s ss r tr r st st rt r s s srs ttr sr tr t s s str s q tts rts ssrs tt s srs t s ts r s st rt ss r s rt rstqs r s s srs rttt s P r r s r rt s ssr P st tr q s t tr 2 sr rt q rstrtr s rs t t r t sr 3 s q t rs srt r st rstrtr t rt r t rr q s tsrs q srt tr t s rt rstqs q ö t s tt r

45 tt rt s t s srs q 2 st r s rttt s sr t r t s ös st rstrtr r r s sts rstr tr rr trs ts q 3 s 3r t rsst rt sr r s2st st rs rssrs þ 1st tt s sts srs s rts rr s rts sr s 2s tr tt st 2q q st r s ss r r s s s tr s tr1 sr s t srrs q sstt rsr s s rssrs tr r srrs ts s s ss tr s tr1 tr s ts q s tr1 r st s s q rst r sstst rts rssrs 2 t rt s s rts t t tr ts s r s ts r rt t s t t st 1sr s s rssrs ssrr trs s r r s ss s s ss tr rt 3 q ss tr sr st srr s q rs s s rts s s qs st r s s sts q rst s rts s tr ts t s rssrs ss t rt q rr stt tr t s q rstrtr s rr stts rttt s rr str tr s q rstrtr s rts sr s s rts q rr stt s tsrs t sr sqs s t r sr st s sts rs þrstrtr s sts rstrtr rs Pþ trts t sr r tr r r r rr s rts sr s ös tr rs 1 t s srt s P s ss r r s 1 t s P s 3 r Pþ tt Pþ rt r s sts s rts sr rstrtr 3 t s r st q t s rt rstqs P r rttr t sq s q þ q st rt s q 3 þ st ss ss s r st tt st s tt st rrs s 2sq s r þ st ss ss s r r q s rss þp q Pþ rt ss q rr tr r rrr t srr s sts s q s tt s rttt tr tr sr s rssrs ts s r r s sts rstrtr rs s rr Pþ r tr r t s Psrs rts st tt ts Pþ rs r 3 st s s t

46 s strts r r s s Pþs rs r s sts 1st trs Pþs rst strt r r sts 1stts Pr s s s tr s t s s ss tr þ r t þtr s rs r r r t t tt tt Pþ t rt ss rr str r trt t st rstrtr q tt Pþ st s r ts s tts s sts tr s t t r st s r 1 s rts sr t 2ts s q Pþ s Pr r sr s s r q 1st tt Pþs trt q 1st sts rstrtr s s Pþs t þ s rtrt tt srt s r srs sts s s s Pþs rt q t tsrs sr s rstrtrs t s r srt r t t r rrt rstrtr s s rts Pþs rsst s rts st s st s r ss t tr s s 2sqs rt s rttt tt rr t ös str s s st r t rss þp r q rt t r t s tsrs st qt s r 1 s t 1 s t s rssrs r t s Pþs rsst r s s t s tt tsrs s rs s rr stt s2rs r t r r t rt Ptr q tt s r q s rstrtrs s ts 1st tt rss sts tr r r s sts st s sts rr trs sr sqs rts tqs sr s t s st t rrt st ss rt r s r s s sts 1stts rsst s t s tt r rrt t r s ts rr stt s rttt ss srr 1 t s ts sr r r tt t st s s r rrr s ssr s tr strtr r q ss r sr r tt sr t rt ss tr t1 tst s ts s st qr s sts ts rs 1 t r ssrr qt sr sst r tt r t strs rt ss rr qt sr q t ssrr t st q r1 rt t st 1 t qt sr tr t tt tr s s sts t rt s ts r tr 2 s sr rts þ st s r r2 r 1 q rq st rttt 2r s ös r t t 3 t r st

47 tt rt rt s s tr rtt s st s st t 1tr ssr t sr rstrtr srs ts tr ss t ss rttr rt s2st st t r r 2qt r tr r 1 r rr tr s rstrtr rs tst rs s sts t tt t rr st s s rts ssrs s sr tr 1 t q st ss st 1 tstrs r3 t t rs t s rts rts rr st r r r 2 tt t tt t rs s rts sts stt st r r rr t ttr s s rs srs ssrs r tt t tr s rs srs s qs ts q s t qs s 1 ts r s rs rt 2 ss s s Pr 1 r str srr t st ssr str sstt sst r s s rssrs s t t srs ts tt rst s2st rt sst ttr s rts rr t s t tr ssrs r 1 t t Pr 1 ss 1 t tr ssr s r s r rt P r r r t s r sst ssr t rs rs tr ttt r s s rssrs rrsts t t s s s r s sst s st rt r s sst ss rr t s rss

48 s strts r s rs t t tr ts r srs ts sr tr rs st ssr r t s q t sst trs rs rs s r t tr r tr s 1 rss rr sst 1 tr t sr tr rr t sst str 1 t rrt rrs tt 2q t t s ts rt 1 t 1 t t t tr qr t sr srs ös tr srtr t r t t t t s rts rts qt q t rrs st s t s ss s s r t 1 t t tr rss sts s st rs rt s rs t tr s sts rttt s rr s srs 2sqs s s s rts t st tr 2 s sr rss rstrtrs Pr s sts 1stts 2 r 1 Pt rt r rpt t s rs ts rs s st s st s rs r r trs t st s q ss r tt s ts 2t r s trt trs ts rs t rt s ts r rr s2st t st r rtt rt s r s s2st s rt t st t s s rts sr s t s tt s ts t 2 s r strt s s s st st ts tr t rstrtr sst st s r 1 t st r1 q ts s rr rstrtr r st s s ss tstrs s q s s ts rs s s s s2st s st sr Pr tt s sts q s s r st s st t tr s sts r t ts r s sss t t t2 ts rt r s ts r tst srs s s s st rqs s sts st s st s qs t st t s s þ 1st tr trs 1 rtr r r rst rt sr r tt tr st s Pr tt rtr s 1s tst s s trr qqs rts q st strt q t r sr s sts s tt s rt s s t ts t rst t tt rs r s rs

49 tt rt ts t ts sr tr þ st tr ss q r st st s st ss tr s q strt r r r t st sts r ts sr r s r rt r rr t t r rt r r rp t tt rsr r t t sr rs st rttt tr t t t r ts t r1 t Pr st strt sss sts rt s t rt s ts rt r s t s 1ts s q s rr t s r 1 t tt t s rtt r t sr rs rt s 1ts rt rttt srtr s s t s r t tt s s tqs t s qs s q t rt t s rt trs s tqs t st ts s s r ts sr rs r r rt tr s ts tr sts t r tr r 1 s r s t s s rs srs sts t trs rs s t s rrt rq ts q st q r t s rq ts trt q s t q r s st r s s sts 2t s rq t t rt st qt r t ö rt rt s ös rts t tr ts s s s sts s q s srt rttr strr s rts r s rstrtr 1 t t s ös rts rt r rttr t s t st s sts tt sst t rt t sr s rssrs r s rs s r ts r t r st s r rttr s t s q s trts s ös sr sqs s1 tr r st s trts t tr ts s r s ts t ttq q rrt s s tr r tt s rssrs ssrs t s s t s t rssts q t r rt r tr r tq r sst s r tr s ös r ts 2t s s t s ts s st r s ts t r s tr s rssrs sr rstrtr r s ös rts srt ss qr rt s sts t rt s rr str rstrtr r t t sr s s 1 q t rtrr s Pr r sr st ss sr srr t s s s q s tsrs rt s tt s s st s ss s r t s tsrs srt r s sr rstrtr sq st rstrtr st 1 ts

50 2t s t ts s sr r 1 t tt 1ts rt t rt ss rtr tt st r strr strt st rttr rssr r s tqs tt t1 Prtt 1 sst rt sr tst r r st tr st t t q 1 st rt st t rt r s s rts rtqs s q s q tt t s t r tt s r r s ss tt t s t tt rr s s 2 t rr s rt rstqs st s tr s s rs strts tr s ts srt rttt r s ts st s s q 2t s s s 1q s tr s rssrs srs t s strt r tt t s2st s tt tr t s s 1 rr tt r rt s 1 t s r tq s 1 s s s tr r s rt rstqs q tt strt t rr s s st t rt r strts 1stts t s s s r rrt s rt rstqs r 1st rss sts srt s s rt rstqs q s s s q st r rr stt s rts 1 t rt rr stt strt s2st r t r 1 s2rs r t r tt t rt strt t r t 1tst 1t 1 r rt rt rt P rt rt ss rt Pr t rt t rt rt rt t P t rt rt r rt s rts sts q strt rttt r r st tt r t trsrs s ss s r strt s q rttt st sr s 1 r t s t sr s s tr s 1

51 tt rt

52 tr r s tr r st rt sr q tr rt r s qt t t t s stt r t r t t s2st s tts str s t r s st s rt q s trts tt t s t t t r s strr strt r q st s rt trt rt tt t s tr r st t rts ts r q tt rt tt sr t s2rst s s s2st s str s t sr s s rts ss P s ts q st tss s t1t s r q s strt r rtt rttt r t tqs tt t1 t t rt r tt r tq stq tr r st tr r1 ts ssrs r r s st t r st r t ts s sts r t s2st s str s ts sr r 1 t tt r s rsr strt trrs q st ss r s rts ts rt rst s2st str s rt rstqs r r r t rr strt r s s2st s str s r r s r1 ts r s2st t s tr st tt r s s2st s Pr s r r rs srtr s2rst t s2rst tr r 1 t s2st rs 1 t t rr str strt s2st s rt tr s sts tr t rs trts ss t s rrts s q t r t s rssrs sr sqs s1 t s2st ttrr

53 r rt tr sts tr t trt t t str st s tr s q s ss t trrt tr t ss s trt s t s s t t st t rsst r rr r tr r t rttt s r tst s rts rqs s rt sr t st tr sqt r tq t s tt s 2s t tr sts s t1t st s r t str st strt t r rr str s2st str s rt rstqs strt s t tr s s t s r 1 rttr s tts qt strt s rts ts t sr s s s2st s 1 t s2rst tr r 1 t s2st rrst r tt s sr s tqs 1 t t tt st r t q sr ss rsss 1 t r st tr t tr q st rsss q rt r r 1 s2rs s2st rs 1 t t r s2rsr r 1 s2st rs 1 t rt r rt t s s tt t rt tt sssrr r rt tr tt st s2st r tt rt rstq st tt s r tt s r s2st str tr tt rts ös s2st rs q trs t s ttr tt rt ss t s tts s q tt st ss r s t s ös st rt s2st s t tr t q st rs t sr s s2st t s2st str r t s r t ssrr t rt tr s rts ös tt s r r s1 srqs st r r s1 st r qts rrrs t r qts ts rs t s trts r s1 s ss t s tts st ssr r ssrr q s2st r rt s s s rts t2s t 1stts tr s ös s2rst t s r rts rs t r t s s2st s 1 t s s2st s str s t tr s s r1 t2s tsrs 1 t q st s tsrs s t2 srt s Ps s srrs rs rq s ts q s rs þ st ssr q r rtt rr s rts tsrs 1 t q t s rt rstqs s qs ttr

54

55 r s 1 t ssr stt s ts rs rrs t 1 sts rt tr t rt srt 1 t s s s sts t t ss s rts tr ss sts s r rr s rts st rr st s ss r 1 s q st s s tqs t tr sts s 1 s s t q rt tr s s rts s 1 sts ös s2st str st rt rs r s ös q ö t rr s rsss tr sts 1 s trt s tr 1 r s 1 t s rt s t ö st tr q rt st t q st rss t s2rst tr s rttr t s2st q s1 t tt s2rst s rt rs r 1 t s rrts trrs s rts tt 1 t tt st s st t srt 1 t Pr 1 stt st sr ö st s q sr ö rtr r st rq s tts s rts tt st ss s r ö st r st sqtt tt rt tt st t rt tt ss 2rtPrt 1ts Prt 4 1t 4 s rrt stt t r 2 r 4 r t t rs stt s 1 s ös st rr st s r s ts rss q tt s sts t st s t rs r st s2rst rr stt r s ös tt s2rst t rt s r rt s2rst s t rt t tr s ös q s s st ts s r r s tq t tr s sts s rs st ts s r r s tq t r ss t tr s ös r s s2st st ssr r s rs s2rst

56 s ts r s 1 r st r t rt s2rsr s 1 ös tr 1 q rr st s tt t tt s 1 t rt r st 1 t sr s ös q ss qr t s2rsr rt s 1 ös r s t r s st rr st r s 1 tr ös tr t s q sst s s r s1 tr s rts ös q ss s rr t s sst s r t rstqs r s ss tt t rt st 1 rs s r rr s rts ssrs r tr 1 s ts stts s r 1 t r s st s rr st s 1st tt þ rrs s rsss r s q t tr ts s r s rts r t t r tr s 1s tr s rts t s 2r s s s2rsr Ptr 2þst Pr ttr r s2st t st rtt r rr s t2s rr stt s tt s ss s q s r trs ts s r rr s tt s s sts rr s tt s s s tt s r tr s q st sst s r rsr sr ssttt s tt s s t r tr s sts r s r s r t2 s s ts r st tr t t2st q r rrt t s r s ts ss s sts t t2 st r s rr rt t t2 tr q st ss r r r tr st s t trrs s tr q rr s s ttrts t srr rt t2 rrst q r s tst s s s ts rt t2 rt tsr s tt s s s s sr t2s t t ss s st s t2s rttt r s tt s r r rts s tr 1 s s tr qtr t2s r s1 sts t r t2 r q t t2 s2rst tr s rts s 1 ös þ r t ss t sr s s ös t s rst tst P s 1 ös rtt t2 q st t2 s s r t q st r srt s sts 1 t t rs s s t ss ss s rr t2 t trs t s sss tr s sts trrs st r s t ss rr t s rt s s tr s rts r s ts s r tr t tr s 1 ös s 1 sts ss t t2 q rr st s srt ttr t

57

58 s ts r r t 1 t r st ss s tr1 s þ r s s t s rt rt s tr1 sr s s 1 t r st rsss st ör s2st r t st s s r r q st rq s s ös r q t s2st ös sts 1 t rs s rt t r rt ss sttr s rts trrs 1 s r r r t r t s t tt tr t 1 t tt tt s s ts st t r trst t st tt t s2st rstr tt q str q st t ö t rr tt tr t srstrr r r r st s rstr st sr t rt s rts ts rrt Pr tr str t s tts sts rt rt 1 strs tr t s q s r t rs q str t s r rt rs rt rt 1 strs tr t s q s r r s t r s s strs stt rt 1 strs tr t s q s r t q q str t s r q s r s s s stt rt 1 strs tr t s q s r q t q ss t r s s strs r rt 1 strs tr t s q s r t q rtr rt r t tr t st rt strs tr t s q rtr rt r t t t r rr st ss r r ttstrsts t rt s strs rsss t tt rt s s strs s s strs t rs s2st ss s tt t q t s s strs q t t q tt ttr sr ö s sr ö r sst rs s2st ss s tt t q rt srr tt rt s2st t q t s s strs qs sst rr q s r t q s s strs q tt rt rrs rs rs s2st ss s tt trt q t ts s strs q s r t q s s tr s trsts s 2 ss s trsts r s s rtrs Pr 1 s tt s s strs rs rs s2st ss s tt r q srt rr rr r s t tr q sr ö s2st ss ss s tt r s tt

59 r t s strs s q tt rt rrs rs rs s2st ss r s tt r t tt r rt s s rts s rr sr st r r tts s ts q t tr ss qr rt Pr s strs st t s t r r qs sst 1 ss r s rts qs t r r s strs st ss t s r s rr q rt r t t r q r r ttstrsts trt t rt s strs s rsss t s rs st r t s sts strs trrt 1 sts 1 1 t t 1 ös q t tr tr str r tr t s s ts 1 s rs tt r t tt tr t st ttqt rstr s r r s sts rt rs str st ts s r s2rs t t t s rrts tr srs ös t q ö r r r rttt r t s trs ös s s ts r sts sr s ös st s r s s2st t s rrt t srs ös t tr ssr q srs ös t t s s2rst rs s s

60

61 r st st s rts rt r rrrrr2srr rr2 s s t2s ttr2 st 4rt t sts rrts t tt2 t st 2 st trt rt t trt rt t rt t r t st r r st t t rt t r t tr r r r2 r st rr r r r st r r s r rrr r r t s r 2 st r r st tr 4 rt tr rts r t t r sts 2 r r s strt s2st tt st ssr tr s trs s r s s 2s P s tr r s trs rst t strr s rts rrs t 1 s rt rt r t s rts s rrs t r rt s rrs t r t t2 þ rt tt rr r t t2 r rtr r rr r t t2 t t t rr r t ts ss r t sr r s s s t rssr r sq st q sr st ts s t s t2s ös r rr st s s tts s q s sss strts s sss strts r r rsst s tt s ts r tt s t2s q st s tr rr t s s ss rts r s sts s strts rt ss t tt r tt st Pr 1 s 1 t ss t s ts r trsrt sss rs s rts sts 1 t s r r s 1 t strt s r t t tr t s s ts rst 1 ts strts q st ssr tr rs t t s t2s ös t tr s ts srt s s rrts

62 r t ss ts r r ss s t2s strts s tts qt s rttt r tr strt t tt r t s t2s s tts t tr r rts 1 t rs r r r s tts r t t2 s tts rttt tt r 1rr q r t2 rrs tt tt r st st tt t2 t2 ss 2t2 1ts strtt2 4 2 ss 22 1ts strt2 4 r2 ss 2r2 1ts strtr2 4 2rt ss 22 1ts strtrt 4

63 r þ 1st ss s tts srt r s rr t s t2 q rrt st tr s r s t r q st t2 Pr s rr t s st ss r st rs sss r r t rt t s tt rr t st t rt rs 1 t tt r r rt st tt t sr s 1 t t s rs r r 1 r s r tt rts r s q 2 ös sr sqs st st rt s st t2 22 t rr t 2 t r r t st t t s rs sss st t tt rr t st t st r q st s ssrt s r q st tt rr t st s rr t t rt st t tr t2 tr22 4 tr2ttrt 2 s 4 t t tr rtt s t2 r 2 r 2rt r r2 ss 22 4 r s tts r t t2 1st ss s q st s qs 1 sts t q rttt s r s rts ss s st t2 2t2 t 1 rts rt r t rt rqs rt rqs st rt t st t2 sr tr sr st r tr 2r t rt st t q s q st rr q tr s rt st s t rs tr st trrs t rt r qt s rt t st t2 ss st t s rts qrs 4 qrprt rt t2 Prt2þ ss 2rss t tr Prs 4 PrPrt rt t2 Prt2 t2 ss 2t2 1ts strtt2 4 1 t r tt r 1 t s sts s r

64 1tst r rs rttt s r s rts ss s 2 st s st t2 22 t s rts strtþst stþst t tþst tt s rts tqs rrst rstt rr rr t t s r st t2 22 ss 22 4 trt strtþst 4 t stþst 4 t tþst 4 st tt 2 r r tt st ts r r tr rt q rt tt t t q t tt tt s st t tsr st t tt t t sr 2rt rt rt t t qt rrs tt rt r rt t2 ss rt st t rt tr s rts t tt ss 22 1ts strtt2 4 Prt4 rt t 2rt tsr 44 Prt4 rt tt ss 44 1tst r r rt s tts r t s2st s s tr s q st s rs r s2rst s rrts ss P1s rst q st s ös 1 t r rtr r r s 1 t ss rst s s tts r rt r 1 rts ss t t t s ss sst r 1 ös 1 t st tt t r r 1 s rts 1 t q rttt 1ts r tt s r st tt t s ös st s strs 1 s ss tq r st st s ss t t 1 t rttt tr s t s s2st r t s rts tt t r r t rt s strt s s 1 t

65 LifeCycleTypeDefinition 0..* supertypes TypeDefinition NodeType managedprimitivetypes 0..* AdaptationPrimitiveType

66

67 r st þtr r t ö Prts s 4 tr224 tr2ttrt 2 ss 22 1ts strt2 4 trt rr strt 4 t3 tr sts t rr st 4 rs tr sts rr tt trt rrt trt trt 4 r s s rrt rr rrprt tprtttprt ttprt 4 rtr t rt rrss t t strt

68 rs rt trt

69

70 tr r 1ts r r t tt t s st rsr r rtt str t sr t strr st r s s tt s r sts sr s rts 1 q st rstrtr tr t s ts tt strt t rttr t s s2st r sr tt r tq trsrs 1 rts 1 Pr r sr tt r trsrs st ssr r r 1 rts s rts 1 q sttt r rr stt s2st t s rr t s s rts r tr tt t rt tr s 1 st rq st ssr r strt rr s tr ss rstrtr tr t t s ss s trts tr s rts 1 s st r st s rt rstqs q t rr strt ts r sr r rr tt r tq trsrs 1 rts 1 þ st t tr s rst tr q 1st srs rs r r strt s2st s s s rt sr s s ts s tsrs q rt s ts t r s s rstrtrs sr sqs s1 tt s tsrs þ 1st rss tts q st r rstrtr r tr s s st s tt r trsrs 1 rts 1 s st r s s Pr 1 3 rt q tr tr s r tt rstrtr r t st rq s strt r st s s tr1 rt rr str s sts 1stts rt ssr strr s tts tt t tt r tq trsrs t rsst s t s tt tss r s s2st s 1trs t t

71 r 1ts r r st rr tt r trsrs s tr 1ts r r st rs r sr s s s s s r st s tr r r rt r rt rs strt t r t 1tst 1t s2rs q st ssrs r rr tt r trsrs r rt r s rts qs r rrt 1 rt rstqs r t s t1 rt s tt 1ts rt rr r tr t s tts t tr t rt sts 1stts q st ssr r rr stt r r sr s tt r tq trsrs 1 rts 1 q st ts s trs t st s r ts rr tts s rts rt rs tts st rq st ssr r tr s rts rs s s2st tt rttt 1 s2st s tts tr sst rt st rq s tr1 rst r r r rttt rr r s strt sqr rts rts rts trts s s2st st r st r st t s t rt ös r ö t t rr s t tt s t2s strts s qs rttt st r s ts q tr sts t2 þrstrtr Pt r st r st t t tr s s s2st s tt s r tt st sttr tt sr s t q rt r tr s rrts rs s r s rts s 2s P t 1 t s rts tt s rrr s2st rs 1 t st r st t r rt r st rrt s2st rttt s tr q q tt s2st st r t rs trs t2s rttt r t t s tt st st r st s s rts ts r rt tt r srt 1 t rrst s ö rt t r st t t srt 1 t r s ös s r Ps st r st s ts rt t st ts s r r strt r s t2s ös ts s s strt srt 1 t t rt q s 1 þrstrtr t Ptr st 1tt rts s t tt s t s tt ss s

72

73

74 t s rss t s ts ss s st tqs rt st rstrtr rtr t s tst t s s ts ss t s tt s t r s s s t sstr t t t q st rstrtr t tr r s ös tr tt t ös s trt r t 1 rts tt rt t t srss ös s q st rstrtr r tr s 1 ts þ r rt qs ts tt st rt tr rr tt s ts t tt r r t r t r tr Prt r sts s tt t t st t srrr 1 t t strt r t Prt rt r r sts st rr s rts tt t2 ö 2 ss 22 1ts 2Prt2 4 rr rrprt tprtttprt ttprt 4 PþþþqsttPrtt 4 rtr t rt rrss t t strt s 4 srtprt s st tt st s s r str rts t2s strts t tr t rssts s t t2 ö r t r st r st s strts t2 rttt t rr s sts 1stts r t ö srt r12 Ps st r st s t2s strts s 1 t2s ö q st rstrtr tr st st rt s t2s strts rttt r s t2s rstrtr st r st s t2s strts rttt r s t2s tr st r st s 1tss 1 t2s r t rts rttt r s rr t s t tr t rssts s r s rt rstqs r t2 ö rt s ös t tt rstrtr tr s st r sr s s rt rstqs s rssrs t s t s rrt r trr rt s r tt t s tts 1stts rsst rt s sst

75 r 1ts r r rt sr r tt r r s t rr r q tt Prtt st ssr r t rr s tts 1stts r s tsr Pr st ss r s ös r12 tt 1stt s r12 r s q tr tt st st tr tt rstrtr t r12 rs t t rstrtr s r s t s ös tr st r t r tr srr t ttr r s ös s q s rrr t s rr tr Pr t2 st t t r s r ts tt r st r12 rs tt tr t tr r s ts st r s sts t s 1 t s q s rs s2rst r r12 1st trrs tt s rs s r ss r ö st 2 ö rr trs ös Prtss 4 P P s t2 s t st t t rs s rt r t2 tt rts t rt tr st 4 tr s t s s tts 1stts rt t s r t s st trrs Pþ t tst s tts s rt rttr ttt tstr Pr tr ss t s rt rstqs t r12 r rstrtr sr s t2 Pr12 t st t r12 r tr sr s t2 Pr12 t r st st 2s ö r12 tr224 tr2ttrt Pþ tr2ttrt þ rt tr Pr12 4 rt tr Pr12þ 1ts Pr12st 4 rt strt ss Pr12P 1ts ts Pr12 4

76 t s rt rstqs s s t2s ös r s s rssrs r s r rstrtr t s rssrs s r tr st s s s s ss t srs rt rstqs s r st t q st rstrtr tr rssr t tr rt rs r rttr t r q rrs t ss tr rt rs r s rssr tt trs r q q r örs s q r qtt r s t t st sr sq rt tt rssr t ss tr trs s2st 1tt t rt r s s rts sr r s rsst s s tr t2 sqs st s s s r s s st tr rr t r t2 ö tr224 tr2ttrt t 1 s 41 1 tr2ttrt t tr2ttrt P t tr2ttrt P t tr2ttrt rt tr 1ts st 4 s rt rstqs r ö rstrtr s sss rstrtr s s ös sr sqs t s1 tr s s2st s rts s þ 1st srs t2s rtst s s t s st rtst ts q rt 1 tr st t t sr srs ts rrst rsss s2st 2t s rr s2st rss r s r q rssr rss r s t s2st st st rt s s s rsss s2st s þ tr srt srr ts t r 1 þ 1st ss rtst s tstr q rt 1 tr st t t sr srs ss tstrs rrst s rsss s2st rtst ss tstrs rt s rr tr trs s st sr sq s ss rss r s t r rt s t s tt sr tst s rssrs rttt tr t s tstr sr s t sr s trs ss tstrs þ 1st ss rtst s2st 1tt rtst s2st 1tt sst rtsr s rssrs t rs q s2st 1tt t rss s1 tr r t sr s rssrs t rs t2 rtst t tr 1 rtst t2 q rts t r s t s2st t rs q

77 r 1ts r r rtst t2 r rtt s rssrs t rs ss ssr r s2st 1tt t ttt rtst t q rst rtst tr s t qqs rr t s rttt rt rsr ö rstrtr r s t t t s ö rstrtr t tt r s r r s sr q t tr s s rsss þp s s rts rrst 1 tsrs t s rt s sts rstrtr rstr tr q ö tr rss þp q r q rttt s tr r st ö tt rss þp st s r tstr s t r s sr s ös rstrtr rt r s 3s r r t ts s rsss þp st 2 ö rstrtr tr224 tr2ttrt t tr2ttrt st tr2ttrt s s 4 rt strt ss þ 1ts ts 4 s rt rstqs r ö tr rtt r q tr t s r sr tr t tt t r srs t2s tr rt s rts t2s rtst q s s s r t s tr t rrsr srr ts t tr srr t t q rt rr s ts s rsss s2s t tr t ss rrsr s tstr rts s q st rs s rsss tstr t s tstr t tt rr s rr 2 t t q tsr rt r s2s t t tr t ss tr rt s q s1 t s2st 1tt t sr 2rsr t2 tt rt ss rt rstq s q st rtst ss t trrt rt sr 2rsr t2 q r t rrsr t2 tr trrt 1 t2s rstrtr 1st s rr t tr r t tr rs 1 t s tt s tr s t2s ös rstrtr t tr r st st r q t2 P t q rtr s rr t s t2 r s t

78 t st 2 ö tr rt strt ss P 1ts ts 4 1ts ss r s t2s ös 1ts s t2s r rstrtr ö rstrtr t s r s tts q rrst rt t tr Pr 1 t r s rs r t q ttrr rs r t ös tr r st s q s rs 1s r st q t ttrr q ö tr tt s s t ö rstrtr q r rr t t ö tr st 2 ö rstrtr rs r t tr224 tr2ttrt t tr2ttrt t t 1 s 41 1 tr2ttrt tp tr2ttrt tp tr2ttrt t rt strt ss þtt 1ts þ 4 st 2 ö rstrtr r 1 tr224 tr2ttrt 1P tr2ttrt 1P tr2ttrt 1 rt strt ss þt1 1ts þ 4 ö rstrtr t ss s r s t s rtst q t rr r st t ö st s r t t s t2 rtst t s r s t2s t s sr s ös r strtr rt s tr ö rt t s rt rstqs s ös tr Pr 1 rstrtr sr r st r rtst s tstr s s s st ss ttrsrsst

79 r 1ts r r srtr rtst t2 s rt1 tstr tr s ö s t tr ö s st ss rr s 1 sr ö rstrtr t tr s t r s tr s 1 ös tr st 2 ö rstrtr t2 rtst tr224 tr2ttrt rt3t s 4srs 2rsr 2rsr srs2rsr srs2rsr rt strt ss þtrt3t2 1ts þ 4 s s ös rstrtr t rr s ts s t t tt st s ssr q s s ös t tt t st rq t tr t rsst r rr tt rr t ts q s s rr t s s r st s s ts s ös ss t s rts tt qts r rr s ts tt s rts rr s tr ts s rr t rrst t ö s rssr rssrs t s str s ö t s trs rr ts rr tt rr s ös t t ss r s rts s t t st 2 ö rstrtr r tr224 tr2ttrt r s 4st sttr rt strt ss þt 1ts þ 4 1ts s t2s r tr s s sts 1stts t r st st ss t st t tst t r s rtt tst r Pþ st tstr t tr t s Pþs st rtt ss s r tr st tt rstrtr 3 st rtt tst s2st st tr s ts s trs Pr tt tr rtt t tr tr t tr t tr t rsst rr st t r tr r tt1r ttsrt1r

80 t sts s qs 2t Pþ r t rt s r s tr rttt strr st s r tt s t st r tr tr t tr ssr rr st st t tt rt t tr t r tr s t s2st st ttr st 2 ö tr st st tr224 tr2ttrt s 4rr r1 3 rt strt ss Pttr 1ts P 4 st r 1 t t ss tr rr t t rsst t tstr rstrtr strt r trsr s ts t r 1r r 1 tst rts tsrs sr t t rstrtr t sr s rts tsrs tr rstrtrs r s rt ts 1 t r 1 t st s rs ö rt t tr rr tr tr ss sstr trt tstr tt sr st s s r t st ssr r ssrr rt s rssrs 1stts s s tstrs st 2 ö tr r 1 t tr224 tr2ttrt þ rt strt ss Ptrt 1ts P 4 r rr st r sss s rts t2s r st s s tt st

81 r 1ts r r r r ss s t2s ö r t s2st s tt strt rs s st r t rt rr str s s 1 rr r st tt strt qt t t s trs srs t tt s trs srs rstrtr t tr t r s tts rstrtr t tr st st s s tts t rr trr rt rssr srs s s t s s2st s t ts q st rstrtr tr rr rt ss 1 rssrs srs sstrr s tts t t s rtt s s2st s tt t Pr12 rt s t rr s tts 1stts t tt s tts s s q st rt rt t s r t s 2rs s s ts rt s r s rssrs srs sr

82 t s2st s tt rr tt tt r tq trsrs þ 1st 1 2s rr tt r trsrs r r sst tsr s s2st tt q s r s s 1 1 sst r rr srs s2st s tt t s s2st s tt r tt rt s2st s s tt 1 sst st s 1st s2st tt r tr strt srt srt t tt rt rttt tt rsr s rts t r s rts rs s r s trs s st s rs q s rt r tr s 1 rr rr stt t st st s s2st s tt q tt tr str r st st t s s ts t rt rt t s s rts t r st st s2st tt st s qtr ss stts q st tr 2s Pt t 1 t rttr r rt rr srt s tr r rt tr t rttr s2st t r rt q tt s 2s s rts rrst s s 1 s 2s st qt r s trs t st tt s q t tr str t q t rr s trs r r s tts t1 rt s t t 1 t s st ts s t2s ös sqs t tt s ts tt s s s st r t 1q tr trs t tr s 1 t tt s ts tt rrst 1 t s rt s ös rstrtr tr s s tt s t rssr t s t t r st s s r str tt r t q t s s r rtr t t s r Ps s r strs st P q st rr rq r s t rttt rrr 2qt s t r t rt ts r tr s s trts s qs r t t s t t tr s 1 ss ts q st rs tr s s ts ssrs rrt t rt s ts t r ssrr rrt t rt Pr t t2 rs tt tt s t rs r st t rt rs t s rt trt tt t s t s rts st st rs s t t tr t tt s r rstrtr tt 1ts rs r t

83 r 1ts r r tr s ös q st ssr srr tr r st Pr rrs s t rrs rt q t t s st rr rs 2 ss 22 1ts 2Prt2 4 tt rstrt rrt trt trt 4 t rs tt tt srrsrrt trt t t t ts rrt trt tr rrt tr trt r tr rrttstr 4 s r tr trttstr 4 tqst 4 tr 4 st r tttts r tr trttstr 4 s r tr rrttstr 4 tqst 4 tr 4 st tttts rtr tt t rt rt Pr t rt r t sst s qt t rt s s t2s t rr s ts st tt srt s stssts t 1 t t tr rr t s st rr t s t st t tr t trs tr rr t t Ps s s tr s sts st sr s s sts st sr s Ps s r trs s sts rs 1 t st s r s sts tr st t s s 1 s tr s sts st t s s sts st r rr s t st t tr t trs tr rr r s s tt rs tt r

84 t s2st s tt ts t tr r s s t tt rr s sts Pr tt rt t r s ö t2 r st ts s s tr s ts tt r strr r rt 2q t s sts rrst s ts t s r ts rs s r st st ts r strr tt rtt r tt tt ts rt t q rr tt r s s sts 2t s r ssrs q s q rr s ts 2t s s t s r rs r r t t rtr s sts rt rr s rs sssrs t sr r 1 s s s ts 2t r r ssrs q s sts t s t r t s rrs t rt t tr tt rt tt q s s sts r s t rr 1 t t rt s ts s ts ts s s s trs t rrst tt ssr r qr rrt 1ts s q sst t rr s s tr s ts tt rt r t t srss s ös s t tt t t r st r s s s s tr s ts 1stts P tr tr tt s t 1st trs tr1 sr st tt s t rt s rtq s rts t rt s s t s s rt t rssts s rts stts t tt s s st trr tt Pr 1 rts rts rs s r rttt strr s s ts rtt r s st s rp r P s s rts t tr r s ts rtts t 1 t s ts trs rssrs ts s t s r t sr 1 t s ts trs rts rttt r ts ssr 1 t r rts st r rr r q ts 1 t st t st s r 1 P 1 tr s rts rt rstqs t tr s rts q s srtt st s qq s r t r Pr 1 t s tr tsr rt rr rtt r q s rssrs ss st ss3 rtts s r rr rt tr tst s s rssrs rs q s st rt ts s Pr t tr sr 2qt rt t tsr r 2qt s tr rt t t sr s s rr P rr st stt

85 r 1ts r r st rt rt 2 ss 22 1ts 2Prt2 4 stt tt tt 4 r s stttprt ttttts r stst rr2stttprt ss3 4 r s t s r rs 1 rtrþ1r r r r r2st stttprt r rst rrt1t tr 1rssrs s3 tst r st rtttr2þrtprt r rrtt st tstrrprttrrtt rt sts t s r t st st r rrt1ts3 4 r t stttprt rstr 4 t s r rssrs st rs sts t t 1sssrsttr 1rssrs r r r2sttsr tst rt st t t s rrttttst st rtttr2þrtprt rrttst1ttst rrtt st r2st r2st t r r ts3 rst t s 4 stttss tt qtr t2s tt rr str t P r s r t s rts q t tr q s st r ts t P s q s r s t ttq rt t s rt s str t t trr strt r r tr s q st rs r rt t t s s rt rstqs rt s t s t rt st st s q trs r t r t r r s q r rttt rr str r stt tr s t tsr rtr 2t rt ts r rt s s t st rq P t r s rs ttq rttt ssr s

86 t s2st s tt r r s ts t r r Pr tr trt str t q rr s trtrs rttt sst r tr r trr strt r t P t s tr r tr r tst s trtrs s qs q rt q st r s rts t s tr r q t s st P q st ttt str st s s t t s 1st r1 s t 1 rst r r s s rr t s s r t P rs s 1tss rttt r s rr r sst 1tss s 1tss rr stt rt s s t s s rts t ts tr r trtr rq trr rs s t sss rrst rt t t s strt trt st rt t q r st t rt st st rt r str tr t rr stt t ts r s 1 t s s t rt r r rr sst s r s

87 r 1ts r r trtrs r s s ts s r s trs s t s r t s r ts st trs t rrs rttr t P sr trt s rs tr r tr ss t r t rttr ss s tst rs r Analysis Output languages from the Analysis ART WS-Agreement... Source configuration and Target configuration Translators... Pivot language (PDDL 3.1) Translators... STRIPS PDDL Input languages for the Planning Initial state and Final state Planning r P str trt tr s s t s t

88 rt s2st rt s2st tr strt rt sr strt t tr rstrtr s t r r tr s r ttrs s ts s tsrs t s rstrtrs s s q t tt r1 tt sr t s s s2st rttrt r rr tt r tt tr t s ts q tt t r q q st t t t s s2st s srs rs t t tr s tr srs s r rs tt s st t tr r rss t s q st trs s2rst tr s ös t ssrr ts t q srs rs ös st s2rs s s ss trs rr ts t r trr rt ö r s rs s tts s rts sr s2st st s r t ts r r rr tt r trsrs þ rrt tr t rsst tr s rts r sts s tr r r stt 1 rts ts r s rtq t ss tr t rsst r tr s rts r sts s rr stt 1 rts q s trs rssrs srs tt r rtr st s s s s q r 1 rtt s r rssrs qs t sst s rs rttt rtr rt rt s2st tr s rts ös 1 t q st s ös rstrtr tr tst tr str rt st 1 sts 1 t ös ss r r t tr s rrts s srtt r r r s st rq s s rr s2rst s rrts s q ss t s s rs t srr rttt rttt rt tr s rts sss r s tt s s1 tt s s2st rttt t tr s rts rs t r t rrsr 1 rts 1 s rstrtr s ss rt s tsrs q r t tr t s rstrtr q r r r t rtt t rttrt s rr tt r trsrs rttt t r t r t s s rstrtr t tr sr sqs st s ss r st tt s r s s s q st s rrs r s tstrs Psq st s ss sr s rrts r rt st t s ssr tr s ts s rt þ st ss s r rttt t rt Pr 1 t t r s rts sr tr q

89

90

91

92

93 r 1ts r r sr rsss tt r tr r s rs ss t s rrts s rss rts sts r st r rt strt rttt 1 rts tts 1 rts rr s rts ss tt trt tr t r r r ss t s 1tst t s st ss t s s s2st s str s t s ts t t rt r s qt s r s t s t t rt t r r tq strt

94 tr t t tt t s st rr strt rttt r ss t tr rstrtr t rttr rr s s sts r tst strt s s 1 rt s rr tt s r tq r st sr s sts s r s2st s s s tr r t q tr trt r 1 ts 1 s Pr s s trr q tr st st sst rq t 1ts r r r t s tts rstrtr tr s s trr st q tst r st srtr t r st r q st rr s s rs ts s s trr q tr strt rt rr tt r tq trsrs t q r sst r s tts t1 st r s tts 2t s ts sr srs 1 trr s rts ts s s r str trs 1 rtts r r st r st tt rstrtr 2 r s rtst ss tstrs r s s2st s 1 t 1 t rtst t rs r s s2st s rst tt 1 rtt r st ss tt str rstrtr t t st tsr s s2st s rtst rs s r rr 1 s tsrs t r qrr r sr s s rssrs r ts rts r rstrtr s tt 1 rtt s s qtt s ssr r r t2 ös rstrtr s q st r rstrtr trr t r s 1 t2s ös t s 1 t2s str s 1 rtt st r st tt t r r rtr s sts t sr rstrtr rt t s trts rt s rssrs ssrs tt s sts s tt 1 rtt s s t

95 t r ts 1 t s rrts s q rt r r st rttr rr stt s þrstrtr Ptr t ts trs 1 rtt st r st tt tr r st srr str s tt 1 rtt s rs t s r s rt rtr s s2st rttt rstrtr t tr trr rt s r ts s s2st s trrs ss t st ss strr s s2st s tts r s tst rttr srt t rts 1 rtts t t s sr r t rr tt s 1 rtts tt s ssr rt rt ts 1 t t s s s s 1 rtts r st s s tr sr s tqs s rssr þt t 3 t r r r r s 2sqs 2t sr t st 1ts t rq t tt st st trr q tst tr strt r t tr t 1 t2s ö s q 1 st rs rstrtr t tr Prt 1 rt s tt t s s r str tt srs t2s ös r rstrtr s q str rstrtr strr s ös tr sr s ös rstrtr r 1tst tr rr s s t r s ssrs tt t2 ö ss tr r t rs s r stts 1 rs s rs r r s q

96 t st 1ts t rq r r t q rttt t2 ös r tsr rtt tt s rts tt s q t tr t s s rs rt r s t t ts r tr r t þ tt s t þ 1st srs t2s r st s s s t rssr 1 s 2rs q rttt 1 trrss r rs rrs rssrs s rs r s rt tr tt r rssrs ts s rsq s rssrs s st s ssts s tt st s s r str tt qqs t2s ös s q t str rstrtr q rt rr 2r s q s s s rts s sr r sr st rtst t r sr 3 t s s rts 1 t 1 srt r s sr st rtst ss tstrs tst s s r þrstrtr s tstr s s s tr st rstrtr tst s s r s s t t t r s st rt s rttt 1 tr s srs sss s s rts stts s2st 1tt trrt rt q t sr q s2st rs sst r s q r s rsss s1 tt s rt s s rttt s t st rt t sr st s2st rs s ss s trs r s1 s s st ss s tr st s rssrs q st tr s sq qtt r t ts P r ör P t 3 q rt s þs rrst s rts s r s s rts rt s rt r q s rs q rttt r s trs tts s s trs rttt r s2st 1 t s s s st r qs st s srs rr qs st s ts ss qs st s tstrs rstr s t2 r st rt r r q ö tr r r st ö rstrtr s s rts s s þ st ss srr rt t rt ss rrr rt r t sr s r tt 1 rtt ss t2 ö t r t r s rt rstqs 1 s r st s rt rs ttsrrt ttrsrsst ttrsr ttrrt

97 t Prts s 4 tr224 tr2ttrt t tr2ttrt tr 2 ss 1ts þ 4 st t tqs st rss t r ö rstrtr t r t s s s st ss s r r rt r s q r q rrs sr r t st t P tr224 tr2ttrt r t tr tr2ttrt r t tr 2 ss P 1ts ts P 4 Pr s 1 t2s ös s rr t s rt s trrs þ t P rttt ss r s rt rstqs rt qtt r s q rssr s t2 s t2s ö s s ss st st rstrtr r st r st r rt tr s ös tr t s s r str t r t s ös rstrtr r sts s s2st s s tt sq s q s ös tr st s sr s ös rstrtr t r ös r s tt r q ö rstrtr r r ös tr s 1 ss t s s s tts t tt tt st tr s s tt t s t s r t trr sr s rts t tt tr rt tt srt ssr tsr r 1 s rts tr r t tr trs rr 3 Pr12 r rstrtr tst s s r rt r rtst s t str s r rs t s2st 1 rttt 1 tr tts3rr

98 t st 1ts t rq st t str rstrtr t2 ss þr 1ts strtt2 ts str 4 t 4 s trtst trttr2rtrt t rrt r rt s rts rtss r ttprts sttr r t s r sþs rr2tr tr s tt r t þ r t st 2 þ sts tr rsps t stsrrt rttststsr 4 st st r sr 4 ttprtsst2 4 t st s tt ss s t t trs ttprts tpttprtsrts rt stprtttprts r t rrt rt 44rt ttprts ttprts trt rt t tr t 4 trrstrstrts tr2 4 2 t rt t rrt t s t t t r r tþrt t 4 s r ss1t 2 4 trrstrstrts stprtttprts st tr tr 4 r2 st t tt rt s 1 tr ttprtss3sþstþt rt ttprts1 s ts 1 t st s ss rr s ös s s qs s1 trt s ts s st rq s s s r tsr st 1stt rttt r r s ös tr s2st 1tt s Pr s s s r r12 t st Pþ rttt s tr 3 s ss rt q t tt Pþ r 1 t s r12 r st s rs sst r r s s ts rr tr r rrr r srr t2 ö

99 t ss s s rt rstqs rt s Pr12þ s rr t s r ttt r s rt rstqs r t s sts s rts q t 2r st t tr224 tr2ttrt þþ tr2ttrt þp t tr 2 ss 1ts Pr12þ 4 s s ss t str rstrtr r q s ös tr sr q s s ös tr sstt s tt q s2st 1tt r st st rt r t s s2st s ttr2ttrstsrst 55 ttr2ttrstss 4 trt3t2s trtsttstr rs2t2t Pr12þ strt3t2ss3 4 ttprts sttr trt3t2sr4 ttprts ttprts sttrt rt stprtttprts r t r rt rt 44rt s 4 r rrr t st 4 s tr s þ t st s t t t r r t s rs q s s ts sr s rts tts t2 þr t sr s Pþs t tts r ts s r Pþ r r s st ts q t t2 rrs s q tt tt ssr r r r t srr s ss r t r s trts s s sr P rt r12 rs 3 s s s rrst t t srss s rts s q srt s s rts r s str rstrtr þr sst qt

100 t st 1ts t rq s r tr t s ös tr Pþ q s s s r tt s s rttt r s strts t2 s q tt s q s t t s rts t t2 st qt s s rr stt rt t s s q tt s s rts r rt rt s sts s 1 t t s rs r r q r st 1 t t st rsss tt s q srt rttt r s rrts st s s t r tr s rts r rrt 1 s r ts s r Pþ r r þ tr ss s rts r rrt rr r Prt r s þr r Pþ r r r r s r s s rt Prt t r rrt 1 s t r rrt rr r ts s tt t s þr r Pþ r t s rt s s sttr q r r tst t rt s t2s t 1 t2s sst r rrt tt s s q r rrt str r r str rstrtr sst ss rt r str q r rss tt s r r s ss r rt q rt 1rr st s ts rt s str rstrtr st r rtt t s t2s ös s s t2s strts rs s r Pþ r tt r str t tt t tr r ts sr tr rstrtr Pr 1 st s rr r12 r tr r12 r rst 3r r 1 t rr t2 r t2 q st trt s sr 1

101 t t st ts r s s t tt st st trr q tst tr strt s sr s tqs t s t t sr ts r rt ssr s r ts rrt rrs ts ssr r t s s rts t r s s tr 1stt st ts t q t stt rtr q tr t tsr s s rts r 2r s sts sss Prt 1 rt s tt t s s r str t tr strt sr ts t 1 ös tr s q t sr qtt r ts r str Pr s s 2 s ts rs ts sr tr tt t s ts q t rt r ös t2 tr t ö t2 tr rrs s s2st rts sr s ös rstrtr s tr s t t sst r r s tstr sr s s r t t ss sstr 2r rt sr trr t sr t s s s s sr ts ssr s rt s t r q ts ös tr 2 s sr ös rstrtr Pr srr ts t s s t r 1 strs tr t rstrtr s tr r ts s q t s ts rs srr q t r t ts r rrt r r r r r r srr rt q t s2rsr rqt ts t tr r r r t t rttt st srr rr t tt t t t r s r r ts s s trs s st ss rtr s rts sss tr r t r str tr tr sss r str tr r s t s ös tr ssr tr r t r str rstrtr tr sss r str rstrtr r s t rt s ös tr s rrt sr ö s rts trs rttt r ts ssr r q rt q st rt r str tr rt r rstrtr t s rrt ttr

102 t st ts r s s s rs st s s ts ts r str sr t r trt r r t q rrs ts rt s s tr s r stts sr t r s s s s s ts r s trr t t sr tst r tr s2st Pr s s r st q ös q rrs sss t r s s st r qtr trs s rstt t ös s s tt tr rtt r rrt t tr rstrtr rrt tr s s s s tt t s ts trtt q ts rr s s q rrs s r r s ts t s s ss t tr str t sr qtt r ssr s tt s s sr t r ts r rr str rt r r t r sr tst r Pr s s sr t r s s r t ts s s t t sr ts t s s s s s s2t ts t rr str rt 3 s s s 2 s r q 3 tt tr s rts str s q s s s r q 3 tt tr srrs rs Pr r s s ss 1tst t rt tr st rrt r s ssrs r r tt t r s s ts rt rt r t t sr ts rrt s s sr r s ssr r t s 1 t2s ö t str þ tt s t 2r s ts rs ts s s s trtr s t rtr qst tst s r t rt t t rt t st r st sr t t rtq sst rt ttsr t t t s ss tsts s s s rs t r rs ts sr srr sr t rr t r q t srr t rt t rt s ts ssrr q t t q s tsts st ts s qq s s trs tr rt st s sr q st t 2t tr t t st s s r rrr r r s rsss Pr s rt s s ts r rt rt r t tt

103 t r Prsss t rt t t rt r rt rtq s tr s t t s s2st s rtqs st s s r1 t srtt s s 1s t tst r s2st st qq s 1 s r1 rts ss t srs ts t rs tsts rttt ssrr stt Pr 1 tr t r s r rt q 1 t s tsts trs rts rts rs rtrs strs sstt sq ss r r t rrsr s t s t rt t q st r ttr rt s ts tr t s r rs ss t s rrrs r s rrr tt ss rt Psrs tr1 t t s r ttr r ts þ 1st r 1 s rs ss2t s tr sss s sts tsts 1 tr t s ts rt s tr t2 r st r s rrt s sr 1 t s tsts 1 tt s tsts s s rtts r s tqs t r ts ttr s t t ss s r rsss rrrs s 1 ts 2 s tqs rt strr 1 t s tsts s tr r tq r 1 t s tsts 2 ss r tq s trts 1 t s tsts t s t tr t tr t r s1 tr sr srs s2st s rts q st trs s2st 1tt rssr r t r ts tsts t s st rttr 1 t rst rsss 1 s st tst t trrs Pþ rt tt Pþ rs ss rr q ss trs tsts trs t 1 t s tsts t tr rsss s Pþ q rt rrr stt rs ttt 1 t t q st s t st t rs st s ss tr r r stt rt s tsts sq rsss 1 t tr t t st r s tt r tq t st ss r srr tt s ssrs r r 1 tr s tsts sr s s rts rqss s srrs t rt t ts rsst tttrp

104 t st ts r s s r t st s r 1 s t srs ss s q rttt r srr s sts s qs sr s rstrtrs ts q 3 r t s 1 tr t t tst s rts sr s sts s tt st trt rstrtr rst st q rs t rs st rt r tr sq st t q rtt rstrtr rr s rssrs ös tr r s1 tr s strt s tsts st s rs t sq r rtt s t r rt t s r st tsts t r s r tsts s r rt t tr tst sr rts tsrs s s tsts tr 1 t r s rts rs q st sss t rr t t st r 1 s tsts tr sr s2st 2t t q r r r st sst rsr rt r r s rsss t rt t sr s s st r q st ts s r r rts rt tr ts 1 t t t tst q t rt ss r rtr 1 t q s 1 tr r t sr s tsrs s qs s ssr t tt rst st t 1 s t r rs t rt t st rs t s t rt t s q t rst rt st ssr r s rsss t rt t s t tr tst s rts rts st ssr r s rts t r s rsss t rt t rrsts t s rsss t rt t s s rts r rt rtt tr t s sr sq rt s rts st s rs rst rt t tt rsss t rt t q tsrs tstr t s tr tts s t s rts rt rs r s s r s sts tsts r r s tsts trs s t rt rs t ss tr t rsst s r 1 t s s tsts st s s r tst t 2t t q s1 t s rr rt t s rr 2 trs tsts q t trr rs rt s sqs s s1 tt s t st s t t s 1 t s trs tsts 1stts r sst 1 tr s sts tsts r t q tst trs r s t ssrr q s s tsts st t s rts st rrr s st rttr r r stt sr 1 t s tsts trt 1 q t s s 1ts r srr t rt t s rttt rtr rt rr rttr t r rrt s s tsts 1 tr tt rttr t st ss tr s q 2r 1 t q ttsr

105 t tst sr s ös tr t rs trts 1 t tr st r s rssrs rstrtr sst ss r tt sstr ss rt r Pr s s st st tr r 1 ös tr tt s r s r rstrtr tt t 1 ös s trt r rst r s2st rstrtr t s str st t s s str r st q s s st s rt r st ttr q s ös t2 tr st s r s r rstrtr þ t r s r sr s rssrs rstrtr Ptr t tsts trs þ 1st srs rrs r t tsts s s tr r 1 t st r s tsts trs t rt r s tsts trs sst r s t 2 s tsts t s r trs 1 t s tsts r tr r srs tts s qs r rss tr tr ss st rs qt s tt s t tr trs t r sr 1 t s tsts sr tst s trs rts þ st q ss sr st rt q st st strr 1 t s tsts sr s s sr sqs s1 trt s st t tt tt st t t s s r t t tt s st s s t sr s rss ts q st rt rs ss strr 1 t s tsts t s r s t strr s tsts sr r q st rss qqs tt s t rssts r tr 1 t r r str s tsts st s sst t tr t r r sr t strr s tsts 1 tr s sts ss r s r s rt rstqs s tsrs 1 t s s st rt tsr s rstrtrs r 2r s ts rs t sst rt sttq s s s rttt strr s tsts r tr r s ts t q t st rttt s r s s r ts ssrs r r 1 tr s tsts trs r str r t s s s rr s tr r t tsts trs t s rt rt r t s rt rstqs 1 t s tsts Pr s rss tr s tts s tts rttt rt s r s rr t s ssrs tttr tttstr ttstrstssr

106 t st ts r s s tr 1 t r st st tts r rt tr 1 t 4s 4s P t r 4s 4 P 4s 4 P 4s 43 þ st s ss r t2 s2st 1tt r örs rssr r q rssr t qtt r s s tts t rr srs rs s r s s s st s r q rt rstq s rt rstqs st st s s r r s s s2st s sr sqs tst st tsts t tr 1 t þ st ss ss s r s rts s qs t t q s rr t s q srt s s r st st tt r t rt s q rt 4 4s 4r 4s 4 P 4s 4 P 4s 43 s s tts s t s trts tr 1 t s rss ss s tts rttt r s rt rs tqs s sr rt 1 t s sr 1 t r st s tts rttt s r s tst st tsts t s1 tr r s ssrr q s 1 t r s t sr 1 t s trs tsts t tr s s tsts sr t þ st ss ss r t tr rts tsts tt rt 1tr t q s tst rs srt r 1 tr tst sq ts tt tst r s st s tsts t r st ss r q s tsts t tr 1 t s r trs tsts tt rt s q rs r s tsts t tst st ss 1 tr tst trs tsts sr tr tt rr t st t rsst tt s r tsts tr rt s tstr s rrs s st tt s r tst rr s rss s r r 1 trs r 1 t tt rr s rsss st ts t r s s2t tsr rtr rt rttr rrt s s sts rrst st tsts tst rttr

107 t st tts r t rt s q rt 4 4s 4s 1 Pr3 1Pr3 þ P 4 st 4ss rrtststtss tst tst st 4ss rrtststtss tst tst P þ 4s 4 t trrs s 1 t s rts tr s sts tt r st t 1 tr tst ss q rsq r t ss 1t ss st 2 r s sts rt s tsts q st tst r s q st r s sss ts s sts t t 1 tr tst q r s s sts rr stt s rts tsts t s 1 t rr stt s s tst rttr tt st s q r st s tsts tt st s rt rs r rr s tsts t r t s r stts s st st st t ts s sts 2t s r s r t s sts tr 1 s sts tsts ttt ss s r stts s tsts qs t str ss r s rs rr t ts r s ts tr t rt st s rs r r t t t t q st ss rs r rr r st ss rt st ts r s s s r r s r stts tsts rttr t ss s trts sr s tsrs 1 t Pr s sts st r s r s ös 2t s rt rstqs ss s 1 tsts t srs tsts t tr r s sr ö s s rt rstqs tr tt þ rt ss r trt sr 1 t sq s q tst t tr 1 t s rsss s q Pr s s t2 ö q s s q rt r r s s rts sr s2st r st r t t2 s rttr st t s r tt 1 rtt tr rt tt tr rt t t s sts sr tr t r ttr r r st s ös ss t s ös q t r r r st tttrsstt ttrssrr

108 t st ts r s s st t t2 tr224 tr2ttrt t tr 2 ss 1ts st 4 Pr tr t s rts tr s sts t st q str st str s s s strt s tsts strt r rt tr s sts q rrs r s tr s tsts s sts tsts þ st s sts tr r tsts q s1 t ts sr ö tr Pr st str st t s s sssrs sr ö tt s st st rs st r r s1 tr t q ss r r rr st 1 r rtt sts sr s ös t t s rts rr rrst 1 s tr s sts r tt r s s r q st r ss t q qst s s trs sts s 1 t tr r r s q sr tr tr s sts q st t s qs tt r 1 t t s st r r s t t s sts sr s ös stt sr rt rt s s t tr 1 rtt sr rt st rr q t s s þps r trrs þtrt Pttrs s s ttrs rt s s rts rt ts s s r t rt ts rs ttr

109 t st t str tr t2 ss Pr 1ts strtt2 ts str 4 rssp trt 4 r 2rP 1 rtrþ1r rstt rrt1t tr 1rssrs s3 tst r r r r2st sttþst r rst rstt r rrt trtst r rrt1ts3 4 r t sttþst rstr 4 rt r rst tr t 1sssrst tr 1rssrs r r r2sttsr tst t t t tr 4 t rt trttr2rtrtrrt t tt rst 4 rst s t rst sssr t s t ts rrt rssr tt rrt s 4 tr2 t 1st t st t t sqtrrt 4 rt t st t t t rt t tt rrt 2 s trr2 t t t t t t 1t trt rrt trrt r2st r2st t r r ts3 rst t tr2 4 trtr rrt t 4 s r rttt tsr s ttrs sr strt s rts t rttt t rt 1 s rt tt tsts ss tr s trs s q t s r s rs r

110 t st ts r s s ts 1 t s tsts r r t qrt ts s tr 1 rtt s s s r 1 t s tsts s sts tsts q st r r s st q rts s t s tr s t q rs sts tsts st s t s s s s s sr st 1 t s sts tsts s srs sts tsts t tr 1 t s s rt s s s s s s s s2st 1tt q s s ös tr st r tt q s tr s rt rstqs q s s s s s s s sts tsts rt ss trs rt rstqs s q st s rr t s r rt 1 1Pr3 s s t s rt tt rt q s r s trts ssrs sr rt r 1 tr s s tsts s trts rsst r s trt sr qtt r q t ss r s ös tr s trs trt tq rrs t q s s tsts t tr r s tr s sts tsts t t s s tr s rts s rt tt trt rttr r s trts tr s rts sts t q tr 1 rtt st t rssr s s s tr r ös tr st r ö rstrtr Pr s s srr t sqt q rt str trr r s ös 1stts ö rrst 1 trts st 2r s tr s tst str st r r ös s t sqt rtr trt s ös r rr st Pr tt t ts s rts ss s rttt sr q tr rstrtr s s s 2t r q tt trt st s t r t t q s tst sr rstrtr t q3 rrt tr r r tt t r1 q tstr srt r t 2r s s sts 1 tr sr s q s1 tt ts st s st q tst s r ts t q s t r ts r rrr s s t q t s ts tst s ts tst s s t t s s tr s sts q rttt s ts s 1 tr r s r stts sr s rt s trt q strt t r st 1 t s tsts trs st qq s t rsst t q rt sst q r t qrt ts r 1 tr s tsts s s rt sr sr s rts sstt srs rs

111 t t þt sr t t r tr s s tr r t r str tr t s rts ts s tr tr tr tr tr r s s r ts s trs r rr st s rts s t r t ss r rs r s trtt s s s trt q s r rt r r ös t sst tr s s trtt tstr r r s ös tr ts s r t s tsts st sst q r stt s ös sr rstrtr s s tr ss q ts ssr r ss tr tr t tr rst rs s trs s s1q r t q s s ös tr st s s st s r s t s2st s

112 t st ts r s s s qr s r r t þ sss r tr tr rt tt r r t tt st s strs r tr rstrtr t st tt tt q rt r 1 t str rstrtr r s ts trtt s s ös tr s s s s r q ts trtt st rs s s s t s rr s ts trtt r s s rr t ös ts s sr r r rt s ös tr sr rstrtr t s rtt st rt t r r q ö tr s tr þp q st s r ts s r s rstrtr s rs s s s s q st ös t s rt s trs st rs ts st rtt r t þt sr tst r t r r t s rs rrsts t r s rts s q s s s ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts ös t ts t tts r s r r st s s r q tst st qq s ts r s s2st s tt t s s rssrs r ts s st tt rtts Pr tt s rs q t t sr s rrst s s ts trt s rt rttt t s s rts sr s s s s t tt t tr t r st Pr 1 s rstrtr t s srr t s trts tr s sts r str s ös rt s sts st s ssr tr s rt rstqs tt s sts þ tt ss r rttt s t2s tst s strts rttt tr s rts t2s t r tr tt tr rr stt st s ts r s s2st s tr s r t þ srt ssr sr tst st s s r 1 r rttr st sr

113 t sq s rts q st s ssrs t r s ts s Pr 1 s r rttt rr str rt 3 st ss srr r q s rts rt ttr rt t t q s s ttrs 1t tt 1 t2s t str t r r st r s r rt r t2 Prt P P Pr r s r r s s rt str tr s s t tt s ss tr r rt t t r s s sttr q t str tr sst r r r s q rt rt tt s t2s ös tr s tss t2 P s q P q rt rstt t st 1 t2s ös r sst r q st r t r 1 t s rts r s ss t s s rt rstqs q s t2s rts s rt t2 P q rt r s rt rstqs s qs r s ös tr s s t2s tt s t t2 tt s t st ts r tt t1 t tt st st trr q tst tr strt r t rr tt r tq trsrs rttt t tqs tt t1 st r tt tsr s rts rs r s rts 1 s ss trr rt s t s tt r rr tt tr Pr r r tt t1 t rt q q tr rst ss r s 1 rts rt s s 1 tr rt s s trs rst t tr rr r r s tts s s s

114 t st ts r tt t1 Prt 1 rt s tt t s s r str t t r s srt r rt s rts 1 rt sr s tts s rrts t r s s trr q s 1 rts s rts 1 rt sr s tts s s Pr s s r str rstrtr tr t s 1s tr sts r r r1t s ös tr rt s sts s s trr st q t r srt r t s rrts rt r rr s trs rst þ s s trr q rt tr s trs rst r s rstrtr t tr rt tr s rts s rts s r t r s rts sts r t st rttt tr s rq ts rs st q ts sst þ tt s t stt t st st s 1 rs rt rstqs r st t s t r ts rr ss ts sr st r ssrr 1 tstrs qt sr sst Pr tr rt st s st 2qt ssrr tt qt sr r tr r t s sts t t tst tqs s srr str sr t s q t r srr t s sts s rr s s s sts r s tt s t s 1 rts s s tt r r str t st s srr t s s r s s s st s s sttqs s r strs st tt str stt rttt rr t rt sts s sst r r 1 ös tr t s ss t srr str Pr tr s t s s 1 t2s sts rr t2 t tr r st q rt trtr s rq ts q r t t rtrr s r ss s rq ts tt t ss rt t r s t2 t tr srr q t sr rt q s rq ts t q r t 1 s s trtr s rsq r t s r ss rrsts s 1 ts r st t st sst ssr srr s s s r s r r r 1

115 channel1 defmsg node0 : JavaSENode response KTinyWebS243 handler KTinyWebServer request content A HelloWorldPage forward channel2 defmsg request B content forward HelloWorldPage

116 2t s qt sr ssr srr Pr ö srr s 1 t t tt s s r t ts rssr st ts s rsq str tt q st rssrs ö t rtq st r r qr s sts rr ö r st s st ssr q tt s 1 t s qs s strr s rq ts tr s sts Pr s s t2 q rt s tr r tr st q rq t st ss tt r ös tr st tt 1 tt q r tr str s r tr rrt tr 2qt t t s ös tr t t q tstr tr t 2r r tt str rst s sq s sr s q r rssr t srt ssr r tt s t r tr rr t tt t stt Pr 1 srt ss t ssr srr ts ssr tr rq t s srr rs s s t r s s s rs srr r ssrr qt sr s r s t t r srt r t tr s trs rst s tr s rts 1 s rt r tt t1 trrs tt 1 rtt tr q tr strt rttt r tt t1 q st tt t s rts s rts 1 st rr s trs rst Pr st t ssr tsr tr strt r t s rrts r rt t rrt sst s s r s rt s r ts tr rst s tr st sr t s rrts t s s r tt s rrts s sts tr s t r 1 rt sr 3 s ss s tr s s ts rrts tst s Pþs s qs 3 rs q s tr s s st rs r t2 ö t r tst t2 strt st s tsr tr rst sr tr qt ss r r tr qq st 2t s tr tr q tst strt rs r r rttt st r s ts s ös tr t s

117 t ös rstrtr s q rttt ss r s strs s s s s tr t s s rts rs r s rts t2s t sts ös sts 1 ts t rs st s strs s s s q rttt r s s t s t r rstrtr rrst t rttt r tst s t2s ös rt st tr rstrtr q s s ts r s s s tr q t tr strt sr st rstrtr tr st r rrt ts ssr r t rr t s s rts s tr s t s s tstrs rts s s s tr q t tst r tr strt st t s t tr r r s s tr q tst tr strt rt r s s2st s tt s tsr s rts s rts 1 r tr tt s s2st s tt st ss rr r t s ssrr r tt tr s 1 r r s tts t1 r rr rt s sts t s s tr t 2 t rt r trrt 1 trs rt rr s s rt rstqs ssrs r st t r s sst rr tt r tq trsrs t rt strt t r t 1tst 1t 1 r rt rt rt P rt rt ss rt Pr t rt t rt rt rt t P t rt rt r r rt s rts sts

118 2t s st t str stt t2 tr224 tr2ttrt s t ttr tr2ttrt 1PrtP t ttr ss stpr 1ts strtt2 ts str 4 ts t s r2 1t rs 4 trtst t t r P ss tstr rsp t t t P t s rr t 1PrtP rps ttrss þtrrsþtttr2t1prtp rpss3 4 rpsr 4 rrt s þt tss3 s st tr ts s rrtttss3 rrttts t2tt rrs rrttts t2tt strtps 4 t Ps r st t s t t rr rt t t t tr r rrrt stt 4 P rrtttstr t2tt strtpr 4 t rt tt t 4t4rrt 4 s rrtttss3 rrttts t2tt rrst2 4 t Ps r t st t s t t rr rt r t Ps r 4 t 4t4 rp rt rrtttstr t2tt strtptt t 4t4rrt 4 s rrtttss3 rrttts t2tt rrst2 4 þ P s st ts t t P tt s t r r 4 t 4t4 rp s t t t 4 s s ttss3 4 2 t rtrs t r rt ttst

119 t

120 tr rt s

121

122 tr s t Prsts s tt t s sst t rss 1 s s t t rtr r tq tt s s s r s tr q tt t tr r t trsrs 1 rts 1 q rr st þrstrtr Ptr ts Pr st ssr q s s2st s tt s rts 1 st s rr q s2st tt st rr s s 1 st rq st ssr r strt rr str ss rstrtr tr s ts tt strt srt ts r s rssrs srs 1 rrt s r 1 s2st s tt sr s tts t1 tt t 1 sst tsr s rts rs r s s 1 tr rtr tsr s t s tt rts r s trs 1 r tr rtr st ss t r sr s tts 2t t sr srs 1 st t s tr s s r st s rt rstqs q s s r tts r strt s rt rstqs rt rr stt t1 t rt t strt t t r t s 1tst t t r 1t s2rs s s stt q s strts 1stts q st r s ts s ts rs s rstrtrs srtt s s s rt rstqs t s strt tt t s rs strt sr s ts t ts þ r s s þ r r r s t s rt rt sr s ts s 1 t r t t s q rs tsr srt strt srt r t s rrts tt tst s ts r ssrr t s rrts rs s s sr r rt st r r st s

123 s t Prsts tr tt t s r st s tr 1ts q rt rr str s s rts 1 q st rstrtr tr t s ts t s rts tr s 1 tt t rt ös s rttt sr rt tsrs sr s r strtrs r 1tst r s s ss t r s rts t s tr t s t s rrt rts r st s s rts t tr ts r s s s ss s s tr1 rt s r s rstrtrs t s tsrs rtr t ö st s rt rstqs s qs t r rt 1 t ss st st s st rs s tsrs t rstrtrs rr stt s s s tt q sst t st rss t s rrts t s r s trs 1 s strs t ss r tt s rts 1 tr rs trr t r t t s tt strt trrs trs s t rr rt tt 2r trr t r t r s 1ts t rr ss r t st s s t rttt srr t tr ts tst tr strt s r rrt s q t sr tst r rr s t rttt trr t tr strt t rt s tr s rts 1 tt rt tr s s2st s tts tr tt rt t s r tr 1ts r s rssrs srs t sst r 1 s2st s tt s s2st s tt t r tr strt tr t s s rts rt s rts 1 t st s r s rrts t1 s s2st s tt trt rt t sts 1 tt rs t s rrt trrs t s rts tt t s ss t rrs q t2 ö t s t2s ös rrs tr s trs srs t tt r s srs rstrtr t tr Prsts rt tr t1t r rt rttr s2st srt srt t rrt r s2st t rs s rt s rrts sst s rts q s rs r r ttr Pr 1 tr srr sr ö st ssr tr r t t t q st tr tst rssr

124 Prsts rt tr r sst r s rts st s rr st s s rttr t s rr stt s rt s2st s rttr st ssr sr tst t1t rttt tr s ts s2st tr q s ts s rt rttr rs r r t tst s rs rt ss r t s2rsr s rts s s ös s s r ts t1t t s tss t t s s s ss trs ss t t s2rst q s rts s s rttr þ srt t rsst r r q r rttr s rs r s ss r t s2rsr s rts t1t s r st ts str s s s rs s tr t s t rttt strr 2qt 1 t tsts trs sr rr 1 t 1 tr s tsts trs st ss s tr tst s2s t str t s ts str s rt s s rtt st ssr r s tstr t tt tstr rs rt rstqs trs st tt t t tt t rt 1 t t s rt rstqs st qq s 1 t s r1 r rqs t ttq s2st st s 1s s ös s2st t r tst 1 t s tsts trs tr t t srt þ 1st srs tr1 r tr tst s2st str tsr tr 1ts r r tst ts str s st r 2r 2qt s ts sr 2t t r ssr 1 t t tstr 1ts rs trs ts t tst s s r ts rrs rtr strt t rr rs s s tt t s tt rstrtr s q 1 tts tr s s s t t s þ srt t rsst rsr s tts rs s tt rstrtr r trr q tr strt t tr rr t rtt s tts q st r s tsrs s ss r s s2s t s tt s rstrtrs Pr st s r s tts r 1 tst s q r t s rstrtrs s st r tr rr rs tt1srrt tt1r

125 s t Prsts rr s s r t2s t tt rtt s tts trs s q s s2st s tt rstrtr tt t s tts rttr t s r q s rs s s tt t s tt s s tts t s 1stts s strt st tr srs rtrs rr þþs q rs 1r q r rst Prr s q Prsts tr st t tr s rssrs r 1 t s ts s s srtt ss rs st t t s s ts rtq s s tt s qt q qtt s s st tr s rtt s s t r t r t q s s ss s tsr st r q s s tr st s str s ss s r t st t s s t s s s st ss t rs r s t rt s s tr rr tr 1t t s sr þtrt r t s rts t rs s s s s t s t q s t s r sr r ss r s s tts t t r st st trs ös t qt st r t s r stts s ss r s t r r t trr r s r t þ srt t rsst r t s r rrt tr t s2st t r r s tr1 tt t s s st rt tr s rs st s rssrs t r s tt rs st s rssrs st s strt rs s s rr tt st strt ts st rr str s rts rt s2st st s rts t tr rss t r strt t r rtt s rrs 1 t r 1 rt t strt s qsts q rt st rt s trrss r s rt s sts rs s t s 1 s tt t s s r t r r tt qst s s tt qst s rt s t s trrss tstrs s s trrss q rsst s sts t 1st rss sts rr trs t tt st s st s s 3 t rst r 1 tst tr strt rrt tr s rt tt

126 q t rr rt q s rts rt q ts st rt s2st s s r r r st tt r tq s rt sst sst rttr tr s rts rt s t tsr s t2s strts r sqr rts rts t tt st st s sst t sstrt t s rtt rsr trs sts tr t s rt q s s s t r ss t s s s s trrs s rs t 1 t t s s tts s s s t s rt sst s sst rt q r 1 rts q t rr s ts rts sts ös t s s ts q s s tstrs s ts sss st r 1 s r r12 rs 3 q sst s s tstr r trr st 3 s sts ss st rr s rts s s q q ts s ts 2t s 1 s rrt r s s rts þ st ssr r r t rr s rts ss r tt s rr s s rtts s2st Pts s tt t s qt r s r r2 r r rt r rs r P3 3 q r s rr trt t t t st qrts qt r s rt r P3 rs r rr 3 q r sst rrt s s trs þ rt r r r s rs r tt t 1 rstrtr sr s ts r r s rt r rt strt tt rr r 2 tt rs þþ r r s rt r rt rs r t1tr rr r tt rrt rttrs þþ rt rt r r r s þ r r t r tt2 t rs strt ts þ r r s rt r r r2 r r rs r P r t t tt Ps qts

127

128 rs 3 tts3 st ss tr t t 3 srs t s tr r rt tts t2stst st ss tr t t s tts st ss tr t t t ttstr st ss tr t t tr tttrrt st ss tr t t t tttr st ss tr t t ststs ttststs st ss tr t t stt ttstst st ss tr t t 2ts tt2ts st ss tr t t r ttr st ss tr t t þ rst2 þtt t rss þtrt t s ttrsssrssrs ss st ss tr t t þ t sr tt 2tst2tr 1rsrtrrss2t rsstrt st ss tr t t ttsrs st ss tr t t r ttsr st ss tr t t

129 s r t 2 t ttstt srtt1trtttrst rrsrt st ss tr t t þ t s s t ttstrrt t st ss tr t t þ þtrs 2ts t tt rsssrssrsss st ss tr t t þ t ttstrstss rst st ss tr t t s ttsr st ss tr t t 1 tt1 st ss tr t t s ttsrtr st ss tr t t t t rs st ttr st ss tr t t ttrsts st ss tr t t s r rttr ttr st ss tr t t t tr ttr st ss tr t t ttr st ss tr t t t ttsstrt st ss tr t t t ttstr st ss tr t t s tts st ss tr t t Pt tttsttst st ss tr t t s ttrs st ss tr t t rpt ttrt st ss tr t t r t rttr ttsr st ss tr t t rt ttrt st ss tr t t

130 r ttr st ss tr t t s 3r tts3r st ss tr t t rtr tts3rtr st ss tr t t r ss r tt rr rs r r 2 ss strt s tt2 t þtrt sr þ t s r s r r rt r r2 r r r rs P r t t tt Ps þ t þtrt þ r qts 2sts ts 22 str r srt r rrst r 1 rt t2 s 2 t3 2 s Pttrs r þ t t r t r r s rttr s t srt t rt rt ts t s2sts tr r r st s2sts s r 3 q P3 ts ts trt r tr P 2s ts s2sts tsr r r 2 rt r s rt tr 3r trr r ts P srt t r sr rs þ Prs t t 2s tr þtrt r t þr t 2 r rr rst st tr r 2ss rt þt þ s sr ss2 Prss rt 2 t rs 2 str st t sr þ Prs t t P þtrt rs trt Prr P s rt3 s t s r 2 str trs þ Prs t trt rs t t s

131 r3 tt r r rtr3t rr r str 2t ts rrt þ t t t strt t str strt s2sts þ s Ps 2 t þ tr t2 1 s rtt rst þ þ s r rt t r r sr t s ts t r 1 r s trt Prr t r2 r ss2 Ps þ þ r r ts rs sst r r r t s tr r sr Prt þ r ts rs r sst rr r str t s tr r þ rs ts st2 r sss t t t s sr 1r st2 r2 ts s Prt s 2 r P r3 rr r tst rtr s2sts þ tr t2 r þ t þtrt 2s s þ t r s t rss r s trs ts t rt r rsr P rt str ts t t r þ Prs t t trt r tr r s s rt tts strt s2sts þ strt t 2sts Prs t þtrt r s þ sr P 1ts srrt t rr þ rs t þ þtrt r s þ rt r t tt ts þtrt tt rtrrtsrtsþtrtt st ss tr t t r s rst r 3 t rt t rr r Prt s þ t

132 þ þtrt 2s str r t r tt 2 r s rst r tt1 r 3 trt strt st r r r strs þ Prs t þ þt r r t ts þt r 2 r P2s t P s þ tr þ str ss r rt r t r strtr r r s qt r t r t t s2st s tts str s t r s P tss rst s þsttt r þrtq t 2st s trs þþ r s qt r rt P3 r rs r r r 3 q sst rrt s s trs þ þ t r s rtts t rt st2 2rs t rtr2 r tr t þ þ Prss þs rs rr rs str rt trs r strt s2sts þ Prs t rst rs s2sts s r r þs tt Prt2 t P P t rrt tr r tt s tr s P tr t þsss tst strt ts s2sts þ rst þ rs tst strt ts s2sts r s t t ts tt ss2 Ps þ s s r2 t rt rs2sts tr 2 rs rr Prtr tr r st2 rrss tst st tqs þ Prs t t trt r tr r s þ tr t2 rr 2 strt rr s t strt rr ts t 2 s t2 3 sr þ tt st23rsr st ss tr t t

133 rr r r tr2 st r r strs þ Prs t þp þp trt r rt 1t rts s trrs trt ttrs s 2 ss sts ss2 Prss P r t t þs rst t stt rt t2 t 2sts 3 t tr s3 ttrrss 3ttrs3 st ss tr t t r tt2 trsrt2 strt t 1t rrss tst sts þ Prs t t þtrt r st tr tr 2 s ts rts 2 t þtrt t þ r2 rt ss s t t tr s tr r r tst strt s2sts tr r þ rsts 3s s rs r rt t tt rt þ rss 3s r s tr þr strt rr Ptrt Prr s Prtr str2s tst rrt3t tq r rrs s tst rsr str rts þ tr r þ Prs t r þtrt r s þ r s r t þtrt r r sr r P rts r rst2 Prss r t tt s P s ts 1rts tt rt t s r s ts r r 2r r t trs rr2 tt Prt 1r st rs t2 q r rttr tr r r r t tt rt r ts r1 rrt s

134 P rs 2 r þr t3t rstrtr s þ str r t r t þ þtrt 2s s þ r t rr t þ Ptrt Prr t r r rs r st s rr 2r r sst rs r r r str rttr srt s þ rsts tr r r2 ss P r r 2 trr r rt srt r strt sr t r ttrs þ Prs t þ trt r tt str r s r P r 2 trr t Ptr r 2 t t 2sts þ t þtrt rs t t r t tt þþpþ þtrt r r s s Prt r ttrrr r r s r st t t t rt 2 rt2 r rs 3q 22 t s2sts s s sts þ Prs t st þtrt r tr r s þ tr t2 þ tr r t s2st rt þt s þ rt rs2 1 rs Prr rt þrrt ttsr st ss tr t t P P3 P rrs str 2 rrt t tt t rt rsr s tr Prr þs r trt rs rst tt t rt r s trt r t rt r st ts þ Prs t r r r t r sr Ps t3 r rts rs s sr rst qt2 t tr t rrt ttrrstrrsrs3 qt st ss tr t t P rts r þtrt t rst trt rs st str t tr s

135 2 rr Pr stts t ts s r s sts s tr t rr Prrt3 tst ss r rrss tst tr r þ rsts t st trs trt r r tr t3 t sss tst strt rt s2sts 2sts 32rs rt3 rr t str 2 t rt rr ss2 Prss s r r t Prr 2 Prt s ss tr t 2t þ ts Ps 2 t þ tr t2 rr s 2 srr st r2 tsss rsr tts r t þrt 2 r r st2 t rrs s tst rt þ Pþ t þtrt 2s tr t2 r s þ s t2 t ttr Pttr s Prr s

136 s rs Pþ t r t s rts t2s tq rrst P Prsss t 2 tt t rt s rts sts 1 t r Pr 2þst tr t rt t2 r ttstrsts trt t rt s strs s rsss t þtr tr r r ss s t2s strts t r rr stt s rts tt 1 rt sstt t t r rr stt s ös r s r st r rt srr rt srr r ss s t2s ö r r s ts P str trt tr s s t s t Prttt t s 1 Prttt t s trts tr strt t2 tr rs r t rttr tr ss trts sr rt t rttr t ss trts sr rt

137 t rttr tr s trts sr rt s 2sqs 2t sr r s r s s rt t s rt Prsss t rt t r s t t s sts sr s ös s s r ts s trs s trtt s r r st r s s rt rt s srr rt s rts sts

138 st s rts t rt tt st s rts rt tt t2 t tr t2 t s rts tt 2 t rt tr s rts t tt rt t2 s s r þtr r t ö rr s rts tt t2 ö 2 ö rr trs ös 2s ö r12 tr rr t r t2 ö 2 ö rstrtr 2 ö tr 2 ö rstrtr rs r t 2 ö rstrtr r 1 2 ö rstrtr t2 rtst 2 ö rstrtr r 2 ö tr st st 2 ö tr r 1 t rr rs rt rt t t P t str rstrtr t rt r t s s2st s tts r rt tr 1 t tt r t rt s q tts r t rt s q t t2 t str tr

139 t t srr t str stt

140

141

142 R sum Le Cloud Computing est devenu l'un des grands paradigmes de l'informatique et propose de fournir les ressources informatiques sous forme de services accessibles au travers de l'internet. Ces services sont g n ralement organis s selon trois types ou niveaux. On parle de mod le SPI pour Software, Platform, Infrastructure en anglais. De la m me fa on que pour les applications ``standard'', les services de Cloud doivent tre capables de s'adapter de mani re autonome afin de tenir compte de l' volution de leur environnement. ce sujet, il existe de nombreux travaux tels que ceux concernant la consolidation de serveur et l' conomie d' nergie. Mais ces travaux sont g n ralement sp cifiques l'un des niveaux et ne tiennent pas compte des autres. Pourtant, comme l'a affirm Kephart et al. en 2000, m me s'il existe des adaptations priori ind pendantes les unes des autres, celles-ci ont un impact sur l'ensemble du syst me informatique dans lequel elles sont appliqu es. De ce fait, une adaptation au niveau infrastructure peut avoir un impact au niveau plate-forme ou au niveau application. L'objectif de cette th se est de fournir un support pour l'adaptation permettant de g rer celle-ci comme une probl matique transverse au diff rents niveaux afin d'assurer la coh rence et l'efficacit de l'adaptation. Pour cela, nous proposons une abstraction capable de repr senter l'ensemble des niveaux et servant de support pour la d finition des reconfigurations. Cette abstraction repose sur les techniques de mod le l'ex cution (Model at Runtime en anglais) qui propose de porter les outils utilis s la conception pour d finir, valider et appliquer une nouvelle configuration pendant l'ex cution du syst me lui-m me. Afin de montrer l'utilisabilit de cette abstraction, nous pr sentons trois exp rimentations permettant de montrer l'extensibilit et la g n ricit de notre solution, de montrer que l'impact sur les performances du syst me est faible, et de montrer que cette abstraction permet de faire de l'adaptation multiniveaux. Abstract Cloud Computing is becoming the new paradigm for information technology to provide resources as Internet-based services. These services are basically categorized according to three layers also called SPI model (Software, Platform, Infrastructure). The same way as ``non-cloud'' applications, Cloud services must be able to adapt themselves according to the evolution of their environment. There are many works on dynamic adaptation such as server consolidation and green computing but these works are generally specifics to one layer and do not take the others into account. However Kephart et al. have explain in 2000 that even if adaptations are, in theory, independant, they have an impact on the overall system. Consequently, an adaptation at the infrastructure layer can have an impact at the platform or at the application layers. This thesis provides an abstraction to manage adaptation as an orthogonal concern overs Cloud layers. Based on Model at Runtime (M@R) techniques which offer to use design tools to build and validate new configuration of the system at the runtime, this abstraction is able to modelize all the Cloud layers. To show the usability of this abstraction, we provide three experimentations showing the extensibility and genericity of our approach, showing that performance overhead on the system (infrastructure or platform) is weak and showing that the abstraction allows to build multi-layers adaptations. Nø dordre : 13ISAR 10 / D13-10