Recent developments of EU case law on radio spectrum management
|
|
- Alexis Carbonneau
- il y a 8 ans
- Total affichages :
Transcription
1 BROADBAND DEPLOYMENT & SPECTRUM MANAGEMENT IN THE DIGITAL SINGLE MARKET: FROM POLICY TO JUDICIAL CONTROL Recent developments of EU case law on radio spectrum management Ignacio ULLOA RUBIO Judge at EUGC Brussels, 2nd December
2 I. C-Lon broadband deployment related to Competition ECJ , Telia Sonera ECJ , Telefónica EGC , Colt Telecommunications France II. C-L on D. 2002/20/EC, Authorisation Directive ECJ , Vodafone Omnitel NV ECJ , Commission V. Cyprus ECJ , Vodafone Malta Ltd ECJ , Commission V. France ECJ , Belgacom ECJ , Vodafone España SA ECJ , Telefónica Móviles España ECJ , Telefónica de España SA III. C-L on D. 2002/21/EC, , Framework Directive, & D. 2002/22/EC, , on Universal Service Directive ECJ , Telekomunikacja Polska SawWarszawiek ECJ , Commission V. Belgium ECJ , Commission V. Poland IV. C-L on D. 95/46/CE, , on personal data-protection directive. ECJ , Joseph Probst ECJ , Bonnier Audio AB ECJ , Deutsche Telecom AG 2
3 Case Law on broadband deployment related to Competition : Art. 102 TFUE (abuse of a dominant position) EUCJ (1st Ch.) Judgment , preliminary ruling from the Stockholms tingsrätt (Sweden), in Konkurrensverket V Telia Sonera Sverige AB in the absence of any objective justification, the fact that a vertically integrated undertaking, enjoying a dominant position on the wholesale market for ADSL input services, applies a pricing practice of such a kind that the spread between the prices applied on that market and those applied in the retail market for broadband connection services to end users is not sufficient to cover the specific costs which that undertaking must incur in order to gain access to that retail market may constitute an abuse within the meaning of Art.102 TFEU. 113: all of the circumstances of each individual case should be taken into consideration. In particular: - as a general rule, primarily the prices and costs of the undertaking concerned on the retail services market should be taken into consideration. Only where it is not possible, in particular circumstances, to refer to those prices and costs should those of competitors on the same market be examined, and -it is necessary to demonstrate that, taking particular account of whether the wholesale product is indispensable, that practice produces an anti-competitive effect, at least potentially, on the retail market, and that the practice is not in any way economically justified. 114: The following factors are, as a general rule, not relevant to such an assessment: - the absence of any regulatory obligation on the undertaking concerned to supply ADSL input services on the wholesale market in which it holds a dominant position; - the degree of dominance held by that undertaking in that market; - the fact that that undertaking does not also hold a dominant position in the retail market for broadband connection services to end users; - whether the customers to whom such a pricing practice is applied are new or existing customers of the undertaking concerned; - the fact that the dominant undertaking is unable to recoup any losses which the establishment of such a pricing practice might cause, or - the extent to which the markets concerned are mature markets and whether they involve new technology, requiring high levels of investment. 3
4 EUGC (8th Ch.) Judgment , annulment of Commission Decision C (2007) 3196 final ( ): Telefónica, SA V Commission (T-336/07). General Advocate Wathelet Conclusions Relevant market 111: the possibilities of competition must be judged in the context of the market comprising the totality of the products which, with respect to their characteristics, are particularly suitable for satisfying constant needs and are only to a limited extent interchangeable with other products. Moreover, since the determination of the relevant market is useful in assessing whether the undertaking concerned is in a position to prevent effective competition from being maintained and to behave to an appreciable extent independently of its competitors, its customers and consumers, an examination to that end cannot be limited solely to the objective characteristics of the relevant products, but the competitive conditions and the structure of supplyanddemand onthemarketmustalsobetakenintoconsideration The concept of the relevant market implies that there can be effective competition between the products which form part of it and this presupposes that there is a sufficient degree of interchangeability between all the products forming part of thesamemarketinsofarasaspecificuseof suchproductsisconcerned [a] relevant product market comprises all those products and/or services which are regarded as interchangeable or substitutable by the consumer, by reason of the products characteristics, their prices and their intended use. [From an economic POV, definition of the relevant market, demand-side substitution Supply-side substitutability ]. That means that suppliers are able to switch production to the relevant products and market them in the short term without incurring significant additional costs or risks in response to small and permanent changes in relative prices(p.20 of that notice) the Court must reject the applicants argument that there is sufficient substitutability between the regional wholesale product, the national wholesale product and local loop unbundling, owing to the fact that in each of Telefónica s exchanges a sufficient number of alternative operators use a combination of different wholesale products that best meet their needs and that that substitutability on the margin is sufficient in the present case for those products to be considered to belong to the same relevant product market. 4
5 Dominat position 146 the question whether a pricing practice introduced by a vertically integrated dominant undertaking in a wholesale market and resulting in the margin squeeze of competitors of that undertaking in the retail market does not depend on whether that undertaking is dominant in that retail market. 162 The possible existence of competition on the market is indeed a relevant factor for the purposes of determining the existence of a dominant position. However, even the existence of lively competition on a particular market does not rule out the possibility that there is a dominant position on that market, since the predominant feature of such a position is the ability of the undertaking concerned to act without having to take account of this competition in its market strategy and without for that reason suffering detrimental effects from such behaviour. 166 Although the ability to impose regular price-increases unquestionably constitutes a factor capable of pointing to the existence of a dominant position, it is by no means an indispensable factor, as the independence which a dominant undertaking enjoys in pricing matters has more to do with the ability to set prices without having to take account of the reaction of competitors, customers and suppliers than with the ability to increase prices However, since all the competing wholesale access products are based on Telefónica s local loops or on its regional wholesale product, the availability of competing products depends not only on the actual availability of unbundled local loops and/or the regional wholesale product, but also on the economic conditions under which they are provided. Pricing 187 itmustbeborneinmindthatitisthemarginsqueezethat,intheabsenceofanyobjectivejustification,isin itself capable of constituting an abuse within the meaning of Art. 82 EC. A margin squeeze is the result of the spread between the prices for wholesale services and those for retail services and not of the level of those prices as such. In particular, that squeeze may be the result not only of an abnormally low price on the retail market, but also of an abnormally high price on the wholesale market (see, to that effect, TeliaSonera, p. 146). Accordingly, the Commission was not required to demonstrate in the contested decision that Telefónica charged excessive prices for its wholesale indirect access products or predatory prices for its retail products. 5
6 190. In order to assess the lawfulness of the pricing policy applied by a dominant undertaking, reference should be made, in principle, to pricing criteria based on the costs incurred by the dominant undertaking itself and on its strategy In particular, as regards a pricing practice which causes a margin squeeze, the use of such analytical criteria can establish whether that undertaking would have been sufficiently efficient to offer its retail services to endusers otherwise than at a loss if it had first been obliged to pay its own wholesale prices for the intermediary services The validity of such an approach is reinforced by the fact that it also conforms to the general principle of legal certainty, since taking into account the costs and prices of the dominant undertaking enables that undertaking, in the light of its special responsibility under Art. 82 EC, to assess the lawfulness of its own conduct. While a dominant undertaking knows its own costs and prices, it does not as a general rule know those of its competitors. Furthermore, an exclusionary abuse also affects potential competitors of the dominant undertaking, which might be deterred from entering the market by the prospect of a lack of profitability Admittedly, it also follows from the case-law that it cannot be ruled out that the costs and prices of competitors may be relevant to the examination of the pricing practice at issue. However, it is only where it is not possible, in the light of the particular circumstances indicated by the Court of Justice, to refer to the prices and costs of the dominant undertaking that the prices and costs of competitors on the same market should be examined(teliasonera, ), and the applicants have not maintained that this is the case here. 201 that Art. 82 EC prohibits, in particular, an undertaking in a dominant position on a specific market from adopting pricing practices which have an exclusionary effect on its equally efficient actual or potential competitors (see p. 189). In that regard, examination of such a position calls for an assessment of the possibilities of competition in the context of the market consisting of all the products which, according to their characteristics, are particularly appropriate for satisfying consistent needs and are not readily interchangeable with other products, the determination of the relevant market serving to evaluate whether the undertaking concerned is able to hinder effective competition on that market (see p. 111). In fact, it has been held, first, that the Commission was correct to take the view that local loop unbundling, the national wholesale product and the regional wholesale product did not belong to the same market and, second,, that a margin squeeze onarelevantmarketwasinitselflikelytoconstituteanabusewithinthemeaning ofart.82ec. 202 Those wholesale products are not part of the same product market. 6
7 Distortion of competition 204. According to the case-law, a system of undistorted competition, as laid down in the Treaty, can be guaranteed only if equality of opportunity is secured as between the various economic operators. Equality of opportunity means that Telefónica and its at least equally efficient competitors are placed on an equal footing on the retail market. That is not the case, 1 st, if the prices of national and regional wholesale products paid to Telefónica by the alternative operators could not be reflected in their retail prices and, 2 nd, if the alternative operators, given the prices of Telefónica s national and regional wholesale products, could offer those products onlyataloss,whichtheywouldhavetooffsetbyrevenuescoming from othermarkets Furthermore, the applicants argument based on the use by the alternative operators during the infringement period, in each exchange, of an optimal combination of wholesale products, which would include local loop unbundling, is inconsistent, Telefónica had maintained the possible existence of a margin squeeze must be carried out solely on the basis of the regional wholesale product For the purposes of establishing an infringement of Art. 82 EC, it is sufficient to show that the abusive conduct of the undertaking in a dominant position tends to restrict competition or, in other words, that the conduct is capable of having, or likely to have, that effect The pricing practice concerned must have an anticompetitive effect on the market, but the effect does not necessarily have to be concrete, and it is sufficient to demonstrate that there is a potential anti-competitive effect that may exclude competitors who are at least as efficient as the dominant undertaking(teliasonera, p.146 above, p.64) the competition rules laid down in the EC Treaty supplement, by ex-post review, the regulatory framework adopted by the EU legislature for ex-ante regulation of the telecommunications markets. Relevance of National Law 328. It must be borne in mind that Art. 82 EC applies only to anti-competitive conduct engaged in by undertakings on their own initiative. If anti-competitive conduct is required of undertakings by national legislation or if the latter creates a legal framework which itself eliminates any possibility of competitive activity on their part, Art. 82 EC does not apply. In such a situation, the restriction of competition is not attributable, as that provision implicitly requires, to the autonomous conduct of the undertakings. 7
8 Intetion: Due diligence 319. In the first place, as regards the question whether an infringement was committed intentionally or negligentlyand is thereforeliabletobepenalised byafineunder Art.23(2)of Regulation No 1/2003, it follows from the case-law that that condition is satisfied where the undertaking concerned could not have been unaware that its conduct was anti-competitive, whether or not it was aware that it was infringing the competition rules of the Treaty According to the case-law, an undertaking is aware of the anti-competitive nature of its conduct where it is aware of the essential facts justifying both the finding of a dominant position on the relevant market and the finding bythecommission ofanabuseofthatposition As a diligent economic operator, Telefónica ought to have been familiar with the principles governing market definition in competition cases and, where necessary, taken appropriate legal advice to assess, to a degree that is reasonable in the circumstances, the consequences that a given act may entail. That is particularly true in relation to persons carrying on a professional activity, who are used to having to proceed with a high degree of caution when pursuing their occupation. They can on that account be expected to take special care in assessing the risks that such an activity entails Furthermore, there can be no doubt, for a prudent economic operator, that, although the possession of large market shares is not necessarily and in every case the only factor determining the existence of a dominant position, it has however a considerable significance which must of necessity be taken into consideration by him in relation to his possible conduct on the market Telefónica, the historical operator and owner of the only significant infrastructure for the supply of the regional and national wholesale products, could not be unaware that it held a dominant position on the relevant markets. Accordingly, the significance of the market shares held by Telefónica on the national and regional wholesale markets means that Telefonicas belief that it did not occupy a dominant position on those markets could only be the outcome of an inadequate study of the structure of the markets on which it operated or a refusal to take those structures into consideration. The argument that Telefónica could not have foreseen that the Commission would adopt a different definition of the market from that adopted by the Spanish authorities cannot therefore succeed. 8
9 EUGC Judgment , annulation de la compensation (59m ) de charges de service public [no-aide-d état] dans un projet de réseau de communications électroniques à très-haut-débit dans Hauts-de-Seine) Colt Telecommunications V Comission, France & Sequalum. 33 il appartient à la Commission de déterminer, en fonction des circonstances de fait et de droit propres à l affaire, si les difficultés rencontrées dans l examen de la mesure notifiée nécessitent l ouverture de la procédure formelle d examen. Cette appréciation doit respecter trois exigences ère) l article 88 CE circonscrit le pouvoir de la Commission de se prononcer sur l existence d une aide au terme de la procédure d examen préliminaire aux seules mesures ne soulevant pas de difficultés sérieuses, de telle sorte que ce critère revêt un caractère exclusif. Ainsi, la Commission ne saurait refuser d ouvrir la procédure formelle d examen en se prévalant d autres circonstances, telles que l intérêt de tiers, des considérations d économie de procédure ou tout autre motif de convenance administrative ou politique ème), lorsqu elle se heurte à des difficultés sérieuses, la Commission est tenue d ouvrir la procédure formelle et ne dispose, à cet égard, d aucun pouvoir discrétionnaire ème), la notion de difficultés sérieuses revêt un caractère objectif. L existence de telles difficultés doit être recherchée tant dans les circonstances d adoption de l acte attaqué que dans son contenu, d une manière objective, en mettant en rapport les motifs de la décision avec les éléments dont la Commission pouvait disposer lorsqu elle s est prononcée sur la qualification d aide de la mesure litigieuse. Il en découle que le contrôle de légalité effectué par le Tribunal sur l existence de difficultés sérieuses, par nature, ne peut se limiter à la recherche de l erreur manifeste d appréciation. 37. il convient de relever que la partie requérante supporte la charge de la preuve de l existence de difficultés sérieuses, preuve qu elle peut fournir à partir d un faisceau d indices concordants, relatifs, d une part, aux circonstances et à la durée de la phase préliminaire d examen et, d autre part, au contenu de la décision attaquée. 84. Il appartient, dès lors, au Tribunal d apprécier les indices tirés du contenu de la décision attaquée au regard de l existence d une difficulté sérieuse au sens de la jurisprudence citée aux points 34 à 37 ci-dessus. En revanche, il n appartient pas au Tribunal, à ce stade de la procédure d examen d une aide par la Commission, de se prononcer sur l existence d une aide ou sur sa compatibilité avec le marché commun. 9
10 87. Selon l arrêt Altmark, une intervention étatique ne tombe pas sous le coup de l art. 87, 1, CE(aide d état), dans la mesure où elle doit être considérée comme une compensation représentant la contrepartie des prestations effectuées par les entreprises bénéficiaires pour exécuter des obligations de service public, de sorte que ces entreprises ne profitent pas, en réalité, d un avantage financier et que ladite intervention n a donc pas pour effet de mettre ces entreprises dans une position concurrentielle plus favorable par rapport aux entreprises qui leur font concurrence En effet, il suffit de relever à cet égard que la requérante n a ni mis en évidence de doute quant à la méthode de détermination de la rentabilité du territoire départemental, ni fourni au Tribunal un minimum d éléments accréditant l utilité du document en cause (definition de zones de reference) pour les besoins de l instance l objectif visé étant la connectivité de l ensemble des établissements publics en cause, il suffit que certains d entre eux soient situés dans des zones non rentables pour que l intérêt général spécifique de l intervention publique soit reconnu. 138 la notion de «prise raccordable», qui est susceptible d être transformée et doit encore être transformée en prise raccordée, correspond précisément à l exigence d universalité telle que définie au considérant 8 de la directive 2002/22. En effet, en déployant des prises raccordables, le délégataire crée les conditions dans lesquelles il peut, à la demande des usagers, assurer à ceux-ci un raccordement au très haut débit en transformant lesdites prises en prises raccordées. Ainsi, le délégataire est obligé,...[convention de DSP], de procéder à une telle transformation, pour autant que le seuil pertinent est atteint. 166 Or, la défaillance du marché doit s apprécier en fonction des obligations de service public envisagées et, partant, en l espèce, être vérifiée à la fois dans les zones rentables et dans les zones non rentables compte tenu de l obligation de couverture universelle imposée au délégataire. 10
11 Case Law on Directive 2002/20/EC, , on authorisation of electronic communications networks and services (Authorisation Directive) EUCJ (8th Ch.) Judgment (Preliminary Ruling from Tribunale amministrativo regionale per il Lazio) Vodafone Omnitel NV & others V. Autorità per la garantie nelle Comunicazioni& others(c /12& C /12): 43 Article 12 of the Authorization Directive must be interpreted as meaning that it does not preclude legislation of a MS, such as that at issue in the main proceedings, pursuant to which undertakings providing electronic communications services or networks are liable to pay a charge intended to cover all the costs incurredbythenrawhicharenot financedbythestate,theamount ofwhichbeing determined according to the income received by those undertakings, provided that that charge is exclusively intended to cover the costs relating to the activities mentioned in Article 12(1)(a), that the totality of the income obtained in respect of that charge does not exceed the total costs relating to those activities and that that charge is imposed upon individual undertakings in an objective, transparent and proportionate manner, which is for the national court to ascertain. 11
12 EUCJ (5th Ch.) Judgment [failure to fulfill obligations of transposition of Directives 2002/20/CE (Authorization Directive) & 2002/21/CE(Frame Directive)], Commission V Cyprus (C-125/09). 42 Une transposition effective desdites dispositions suppose ainsi non seulement que l autorité compétente pour l octroi de tels droits soit clairement désignée, mais aussi que des procédures administratives transparentes soient établies pour la mise en œuvre de ceux-ci. 43. Or, le régime d autorisation en cause en matière de délivrance de droits de passage sur le domaine public manque de transparence. 44. D une part, il est constant que les autorités nationales compétentes ont procédé, lors du traitement des demandes de permis de construire ou d urbanisme, à une évaluation de l impact environnemental des champs électromagnétiques, bien qu une telle évaluation ne fût pas prévue par la législation nationale. 45. D autre part, force est de constater que la République de Chypre admet des retards relatifs à l octroi des droits de passages en ce qui concerne l installation de mâts et d antennes, ces retards résultant du chevauchement des compétences entre les autorités chargées de délivrer les permis de construire et d urbanisme. 46. Dans ces conditions, il y a lieu de constater que, en ne garantissant pas l octroi de droits de passage sur, au dessus ou au-dessous de propriétés publiques sur la base de procédures transparentes, appliquées sans discrimination et sans retard, conformément aux articles 11, paragraphe 1, de la directive «cadre», et de l article 4, paragraphe 1, de la directive «autorisation», la République de Chypre a manqué aux obligations qui lui incombent en vertu de ces directives. 12
13 EUCJ Judgment (3 rd Ch.) (preliminary ruling from Qorti Kostituzzjonali di Malta) Vodafone Malta Ltd. & others V Avukat Ġenerali& others (C-71/12): 25. On the other hand, a charge the trigger for which is linked not to a general authorisation procedure for access to the electronic telecommunications services market but to the use of mobile telephony services provided by operators and which is ultimately borne by the user of suchservicesdoesnotfallwithinthescopeofart.12ad. 27 thechargeatissueinthemainproceedingsisreferredtoas exciseduty, that it is not levied on all electronic telecommunications operators holding a general authorisation but only on operators proving mobile telephony services that charge is paid to the mobile telephony operators by their users on an individual basis, the sum in question subsequently being passed on to the Comptroller of Customs by all operators providing mobile telephony services and being payable only by those operators and not by other undertakings, including those providing electronic communications networks and other services. 28. In the light of those considerations, it would appear that the charge at issueinthemainproceedingsisakintoataxonconsumption,whichisamatter for the national court to verify. If that is indeed the case, that charge does not fallwithinthescopeofart.12ofad. 13
14 EUCJ (3rd Ch.) Judgment (failure to fulfill obligations of Directive 2002/20/CE) Commission V France (C- 485/11). 33. En l occurrence, il y a lieu de relever que, ainsi qu il ressort du libellé de l article 302 bis KH du CGI, le fait générateur de la taxe litigieuse prévue à cet article est lié à la fourniture d un service en France par tout opérateur de communications électroniques et. L article 302 bis KH du CGI prévoit qu un opérateur ne devient redevable de cette taxe litigieuse que lorsque ses revenus pour les services aux usagers finals excèdent 5 millions. Les opérateurs de communications électroniques qui fournissent des prestations d interconnexion, d accès, de diffusion ou de transport des services de communications audiovisuelles ne sont pas redevables de la taxe litigieuse. 34 Il en découle que la taxe litigieuse est imposée non pas à tous les opérateurs de communications électroniques titulaires d une autorisation générale ou d un droit d utilisation des radiofréquences ou des numéros, mais aux opérateurs titulaires d une autorisation générale qui fournissent déjà leurs services sur le marché des services de communications électroniques aux usagers finals. De plus, les conditions d imposition de cette taxe énoncées à l article 302 bis KH du CGI montrent qu elle n est pas imposée [que] à l activité de l opérateur consistant à fournir des prestations de communications électroniques aux usagers finals en France. Par conséquent, il y a lieu de considérer que le fait générateur de la taxe litigieuse n est pas lié à la procédure d autorisation générale ou à l octroi d un droit d utilisation des radiofréquences ou des numéros. Dès lors, elle ne relève pas du champ d application de l article 12 de la directive «autorisation». 14
15 EUCJ (4 th Ch.) Judgment (preliminary ruling from the Belgium Constitutional Court) Belgacom, Mobistar & KPN Group SA V Belgium (C-375/11). 54 Arts 12 and 13 of the Authorisation Directive must be interpreted as not precluding a MSfrom charging mobile telephone operators holding rights of use for radio-frequencies a oneofffeepayableforbothanewacquisitionof rights ofuseforradio frequenciesandforrenewals of those rights, in addition to an annual fee for making the frequencies available, intended to encourage optimal use of the resources while at the same time also covering the cost of managing the authorisation, provided that those fees genuinely are intended to ensure optimal use of the resource made up of those radio frequencies [promotion of competition] and are objectively justified, transparent, non-discriminatory and proportionate in relation to their intended purpose and take into account the objectives in Art. 8 of the Framework Directive, whichitisforthenational courttoassess. 55 the fixing of the amount of a one-off fee for rights of use for radio frequencies by reference either to the amount of the former one-off licence fee calculated on the basis of the number of frequencies and months to which the rights of use relate, or to the amounts raised through auction, may be an appropriate method for determining the value of the radio frequencies Art. 14(1) of the Authorisation Directive not precluding a MS from charging a mobile telephone operator a fee such as, provided that that amendment is objectively justified and effected in a proportionate manner and notice has been given to all interested parties in order toenablethemtoexpresstheirviews,whichitisforthenational courttoassess the fact of charging mobile telephone operators fees such as those at issue in the main proceedings is not liable to influence the content and scope of the rights of use for radio frequencies granted to the operators concerned. Consequently, the amendment to the fees scheme is not a restriction or withdrawal of the rights of use for radio frequencies for the purposes of Article 14(2) of the Authorisation Directive. 15
16 EUCJ (4th Ch.) Judgment preliminary ruling from the Tribunal Supremo(Spain) Vodafone Spn SA V Ayuntamiento de Staª Amalia y de Tudela// France Telecom Spn. SA V Ayuntamiento de Torremayor(C- 55/11, 57-58/11). 35 Article 13 of the Authorisation Directive must be interpreted as precluding the imposition of a fee for the right to install facilities on, over or under public or private property on operating undertakings which, without being proprietors of those facilities, use them to provide mobile telephony services. 38 Art. 13 of the Authorisation Directive satisfies those criteria (direct effect). That provision provides, in unconditional and precise terms, that MS may imposefees forrights in three specific cases, namely for the rights of use for radio frequencies or numbers or for the rights to install facilities on, over or under public or private property. 16
17 EUCJ (3rd Ch.) Judgment , preliminary ruling from the Tribunal Supremo(Spain) at Telefónica Móviles España SA V A.E. & SE de Telecomunicaciones(C- 85/10). 34 a charge imposed on operators of telecommunications services for the use of scarce resources must ensure an optimal use of those resources and must take account of the need to foster the development of innovative services and competition cannot, in light of the foregoing, preclude MS from establishing, for the purposes of determining the amount of that charge, a distinction even a significant one between, on the one hand, the digital or analogue technology used and, on the other, within each technology, the different uses which are made of it, so that equality of opportunity is secured as between the various economic operators. 35. In addition, those requirements cannot, in principle, prevent MS from increasing, even significantly, the charge payable for a particular technology in response to both technical and economic developments on the market for telecommunications services, but leaving unchanged the charge for another technology, provided that the different amounts imposed reflect the respective economic values of the uses made of the scarce resource at issue. 36. Lastly, the sole fact that such an increase in the amount of the charge is substantial does not in itself mean that this is incompatible with the purpose that a charge for the use of scarce resources must have under Art. 11(2) of Directive 97/13, provided that the charge is neither excessive nor too low. 38. the requirements laid down in Art. 11(2) of Directive 97/13, do indeed influence the level of that charge, but do not oblige MS to use that charge for a particular purpose or to use the income from that charge in a particular manner. 40 the answer to the questions referred is that the requirements laid down in Art. 11(2) of Directive 97/13 under which a charge imposed on operators of telecommunications services for the use of scarce resources.must be interpreted as not precluding national legislation which provides for a fee to be levied on operators of telecommunications services holding individual licences for the use of radio frequencies, but does not allocate a specific use to the income derived from that fee, and which significantly increases the fee for a particular technology but leaves it unchanged for another. 17
18 EUCJ (7th CH.) Judgment , preliminary ruling from the Tribunal Supremo (Spain) at Telefónica de España SA V AE. (C-284/10). 29 Directive 97/13 merely states, in Arts 6 and 11, that the fees imposed on holders of general authorisations and holders of individual licences may seek only to cover the administrative costs incurred respectively in the issue, management, control and enforcement of the applicable general authorisations scheme or the individual licences Art. 6 does not impose the requirement of a proportionate relationship between the fee applicable to general authorisations granted to a chargeable operator and the work involved in the issue, management, control and enforcement of those general authorisations for that operator. 30 Art. 12 of the Authorisation Directive provides that any administrative charges incurred in the enforcement of the general authorisation scheme are to be imposed upon the individual undertakings in a proportionate manner. It follows that the criterion of proportionality provided for in Art. 12 relates to the imposition of administrative costs upon chargeable persons and not to the relationship between the fee applicable to general authorisations and the work involved. 31. MS are entitled to determine the amount of that fee on the basis of the gross operating income of the chargeable persons, firstly, whether it is an objective, transparent and non-discriminatory criterion. Secondly, that criterion for determining the amount is not unconnected with the costs incurred by the competent national authority. 34. MS may impose on holders of general authorisations an annual fee aimed at defraying administrative costs, [and] may be made liable to pay a fee to cover, in addition to the costs of issuing the general authorisation, the administrative costs incurred in the management, control and enforcement of the authorisation during its period of validity. 35 legislation of a MS introducing a fee imposed on holders of general authorisations, to the extent that the combinedrevenuereceived bythatms bywayof suchafeedoesnotexceedallof thoseadministrativecosts. Ee 18
19 Case Law on Directive 2002/21/EC, , on a common regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services (Framework Directive) & Directive 2002/22/EC, , on universal service and users rights relating to electronic communications networks and services (Universal Service Directive) EUCJ (3rd Ch.) Judgment (preliminary ruling from the Polska Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny) Telekomunikacja Polska SawWarszawie V Prezes Urzędu Komunikacji Elektronicznej PUKE(C-522/08) 30 the Framework Directive and the Universal Service Directive cannot preclude national legislation, such as that at issue in the main proceedings, which, for the purpose of protecting end-users, prohibits an undertaking from making the conclusion of a contract for the provision of telecommunications services contingent on the conclusion, by the end-user, of a contract for the provision of other services. 33 However, Directive 2005/29 must be interpreted as precluding national legislation which, with certain exceptions, and without taking account of the specific circumstances, imposes a general prohibition of combined offers made byavendortoaconsumer. EUTG(7 th Ch.)Order ; EUCJ(8 th Ch.)Judgment (Appeal) PUKE&Poland VCommission (rejects Cassation) 19
20 EUCJ (3rd Ch.) Judgment , failure to fulfill obligations of Directive 2002/22/CE: Comission V Belgium(C-134/10). 42. the designation of certain television channels as being subject to the must-carry obligation, under Art.13 of the Law of , constitutes a restriction of the freedom to provide services within the meaning ofart.56tfeu,asthecourthasalreadyheld. 44 a cultural policy may constitute an overriding requirement relating to the general interest which justifies a restriction of the freedom to provide services 54 Clearly, the mere statement of a general policy objective, which is not accompanied by any additional factor capable of enabling operators to determine in advance the nature and effect of the precise conditions and obligations to be fulfilled if they apply for the award of must-carry status, does not permit these requirements to be met. 55. Consequently, it must be held that the 2 nd indent of the 1 st paragraph of Art. 13 of the Law of does not clearly define the actual criteria relied upon by the national authorities to select the television broadcasters benefiting from the must-carry obligation and that that provision is not, therefore, sufficiently precise to ensure that the broadcasters thus selected are those whose content, in its entirety, is capable of meeting the general interest cultural objective pursued. 60 the criteria to be met for the award of must-carry status are unknown to the non-public television broadcasters capable of benefiting from the must-carry obligation. Consequently, such a procedure does not observe the principle of transparency, as provided for in Art. 31(1) of the Universal Service Directive. 64. a Royal Decrete designate, as benefiting from the must-carry obligation, non-public broadcasters coming under the powers of the French and Flemish Communities, so that all the programmes broadcast by those broadcasters would automatically benefit from that obligation irrespective of the overall content of those programmes and their ability to meet the legitimate general interest objectives 68 It is unclear from the 2 nd indent of the 1 st paragraph of Art. 13 of the Law of what the effect of the requirement is that non-public broadcasters must fall under the powers of the Belgian Community in order to benefit from must-carry status. 20
First Nations Assessment Inspection Regulations. Règlement sur l inspection aux fins d évaluation foncière des premières nations CONSOLIDATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION First Nations Assessment Inspection Regulations Règlement sur l inspection aux fins d évaluation foncière des premières nations SOR/2007-242 DORS/2007-242 Current to September
Plus en détailCredit Note and Debit Note Information (GST/ HST) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Credit Note and Debit Note Information (GST/ HST) Regulations Règlement sur les renseignements à inclure dans les notes de crédit et les notes de débit (TPS/ TVH) SOR/91-44
Plus en détailRULE 5 - SERVICE OF DOCUMENTS RÈGLE 5 SIGNIFICATION DE DOCUMENTS. Rule 5 / Règle 5
RULE 5 - SERVICE OF DOCUMENTS General Rules for Manner of Service Notices of Application and Other Documents 5.01 (1) A notice of application or other document may be served personally, or by an alternative
Plus en détailAPPENDIX 2. Provisions to be included in the contract between the Provider and the. Holder
Page 1 APPENDIX 2 Provisions to be included in the contract between the Provider and the Obligations and rights of the Applicant / Holder Holder 1. The Applicant or Licensee acknowledges that it has read
Plus en détailCheque Holding Policy Disclosure (Banks) Regulations. Règlement sur la communication de la politique de retenue de chèques (banques) CONSOLIDATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Cheque Holding Policy Disclosure (Banks) Regulations Règlement sur la communication de la politique de retenue de chèques (banques) SOR/2002-39 DORS/2002-39 Current to
Plus en détailCalculation of Interest Regulations. Règlement sur le calcul des intérêts CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION. Current to August 4, 2015 À jour au 4 août 2015
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Calculation of Interest Regulations Règlement sur le calcul des intérêts SOR/87-631 DORS/87-631 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour au 4 août 2015 Published by the Minister
Plus en détailAPPENDIX 6 BONUS RING FORMAT
#4 EN FRANÇAIS CI-DESSOUS Preamble and Justification This motion is being presented to the membership as an alternative format for clubs to use to encourage increased entries, both in areas where the exhibitor
Plus en détailSupport Orders and Support Provisions (Banks and Authorized Foreign Banks) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Support Orders and Support Provisions (Banks and Authorized Foreign Banks) Regulations Règlement sur les ordonnances alimentaires et les dispositions alimentaires (banques
Plus en détailBill 12 Projet de loi 12
1ST SESSION, 41ST LEGISLATURE, ONTARIO 63 ELIZABETH II, 2014 1 re SESSION, 41 e LÉGISLATURE, ONTARIO 63 ELIZABETH II, 2014 Bill 12 Projet de loi 12 An Act to amend the Employment Standards Act, 2000 with
Plus en détailInterest Rate for Customs Purposes Regulations. Règlement sur le taux d intérêt aux fins des douanes CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Interest Rate for Customs Purposes Regulations Règlement sur le taux d intérêt aux fins des douanes SOR/86-1121 DORS/86-1121 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour au 4 août
Plus en détailNatixis Asset Management Response to the European Commission Green Paper on shadow banking
European Commission DG MARKT Unit 02 Rue de Spa, 2 1049 Brussels Belgium markt-consultation-shadow-banking@ec.europa.eu 14 th June 2012 Natixis Asset Management Response to the European Commission Green
Plus en détailRèglement sur le télémarketing et les centres d'appel. Call Centres Telemarketing Sales Regulation
THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT (C.C.S.M. c. C200) Call Centres Telemarketing Sales Regulation LOI SUR LA PROTECTION DU CONSOMMATEUR (c. C200 de la C.P.L.M.) Règlement sur le télémarketing et les centres d'appel
Plus en détailINVESTMENT REGULATIONS R-090-2001 In force October 1, 2001. RÈGLEMENT SUR LES INVESTISSEMENTS R-090-2001 En vigueur le 1 er octobre 2001
FINANCIAL ADMINISTRATION ACT INVESTMENT REGULATIONS R-090-2001 In force October 1, 2001 LOI SUR LA GESTION DES FINANCES PUBLIQUES RÈGLEMENT SUR LES INVESTISSEMENTS R-090-2001 En vigueur le 1 er octobre
Plus en détailLoi sur l aide financière à la Banque Commerciale du Canada. Canadian Commercial Bank Financial Assistance Act CODIFICATION CONSOLIDATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Canadian Commercial Bank Financial Assistance Act Loi sur l aide financière à la Banque Commerciale du Canada S.C. 1985, c. 9 S.C. 1985, ch. 9 Current to September 10,
Plus en détailPublic and European Business Law - Droit public et européen des affaires. Master I Law Level
Public and European Business Law - Droit public et européen des affaires Stéphane de La Rosa Master I Law Level Delivered Lectures Jean Monnet Chair «Droit de l Union Européenne et Mutations de l intégration
Plus en détailAMENDMENT TO BILL 32 AMENDEMENT AU PROJET DE LOI 32
THAT the proposed clause 6(1), as set out in Clause 6(1) of the Bill, be replaced with the following: Trustee to respond promptly 6(1) A trustee shall respond to a request as promptly as required in the
Plus en détailAir Transportation Tax Order, 1995. Décret de 1995 sur la taxe de transport aérien CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Air Transportation Tax Order, 1995 Décret de 1995 sur la taxe de transport aérien SOR/95-206 DORS/95-206 Current to August 30, 2015 À jour au 30 août 2015 Published by
Plus en détailDisclosure on Account Opening by Telephone Request (Trust and Loan Companies) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Disclosure on Account Opening by Telephone Request (Trust and Loan Companies) Regulations Règlement sur la communication en cas de demande téléphonique d ouverture de
Plus en détailRèglement relatif à l examen fait conformément à la Déclaration canadienne des droits. Canadian Bill of Rights Examination Regulations CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Canadian Bill of Rights Examination Regulations Règlement relatif à l examen fait conformément à la Déclaration canadienne des droits C.R.C., c. 394 C.R.C., ch. 394 Current
Plus en détailImport Allocation Regulations. Règlement sur les autorisations d importation CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Import Allocation Regulations Règlement sur les autorisations d importation SOR/95-36 DORS/95-36 Current to May 17, 2011 À jour au 1 er 17 mai 2011 Published by the Minister
Plus en détailINDIVIDUALS AND LEGAL ENTITIES: If the dividends have not been paid yet, you may be eligible for the simplified procedure.
Recipient s name 5001-EN For use by the foreign tax authority CALCULATION OF WITHHOLDING TAX ON DIVIDENDS Attachment to Form 5000 12816*01 INDIVIDUALS AND LEGAL ENTITIES: If the dividends have not been
Plus en détailDisclosure on Account Opening by Telephone Request (Retail Associations) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Disclosure on Account Opening by Telephone Request (Retail Associations) Regulations Règlement sur la communication en cas de demande téléphonique d ouverture de compte
Plus en détailTHE LAW SOCIETY OF UPPER CANADA BY-LAW 19 [HANDLING OF MONEY AND OTHER PROPERTY] MOTION TO BE MOVED AT THE MEETING OF CONVOCATION ON JANUARY 24, 2002
2-aes THE LAW SOCIETY OF UPPER CANADA BY-LAW 19 [HANDLING OF MONEY AND OTHER PROPERTY] MOTION TO BE MOVED AT THE MEETING OF CONVOCATION ON JANUARY 24, 2002 MOVED BY SECONDED BY THAT By-Law 19 [Handling
Plus en détailInput Tax Credit Information (GST/HST) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Input Tax Credit Information (GST/HST) Regulations Règlement sur les renseignements nécessaires à une demande de crédit de taxe sur les intrants (TPS/ TVH) SOR/91-45 DORS/91-45
Plus en détailExport Permit (Steel Monitoring) Regulations. Règlement sur les licences d exportation (surveillance de l acier) CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Export Permit (Steel Monitoring) Regulations Règlement sur les licences d exportation (surveillance de l acier) SOR/87-321 DORS/87-321 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailDiscours du Ministre Tassarajen Pillay Chedumbrum. Ministre des Technologies de l'information et de la Communication (TIC) Worshop on Dot.
Discours du Ministre Tassarajen Pillay Chedumbrum Ministre des Technologies de l'information et de la Communication (TIC) Worshop on Dot.Mu Date: Jeudi 12 Avril 2012 L heure: 9h15 Venue: Conference Room,
Plus en détail22/09/2014 sur la base de 55,03 euros par action
CORPORATE EVENT NOTICE: Amortissement d'orane Reprise de cotation PUBLICIS GROUPE S.A. PLACE: Paris AVIS N : PAR_20140902_06559_EUR DATE: 02/09/2014 MARCHE: EURONEXT PARIS Amortissement en titres et en
Plus en détailBill 204 Projet de loi 204
3RD SESSION, 37TH LEGISLATURE, ONTARIO 51 ELIZABETH II, 2002 3 e SESSION, 37 e LÉGISLATURE, ONTARIO 51 ELIZABETH II, 2002 Bill 204 Projet de loi 204 An Act to amend the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998 to
Plus en détailOUVRIR UN COMPTE CLIENT PRIVÉ
OUVRIR UN COMPTE CLIENT PRIVÉ LISTE DE VERIFICATION Pour éviter tous retards dans le traitement de votre application pour l ouverture d un compte avec Oxford Markets ( OM, l Entreprise ) Veuillez suivre
Plus en détailLife Companies Borrowing Regulations. Règlement sur les emprunts des sociétés d assurance-vie CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Life Companies Borrowing Regulations Règlement sur les emprunts des sociétés d assurance-vie SOR/92-277 DORS/92-277 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour au 4 août 2015 Published
Plus en détailForm of Deeds Relating to Certain Successions of Cree and Naskapi Beneficiaries Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Form of Deeds Relating to Certain Successions of Cree and Naskapi Beneficiaries Regulations Règlement sur la forme des actes relatifs à certaines successions de bénéficiaires
Plus en détailName Use (Affiliates of Banks or Bank Holding Companies) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Name Use (Affiliates of Banks or Bank Holding Companies) Regulations Règlement sur l utilisation de la dénomination sociale (entités du même groupe qu une banque ou société
Plus en détailBorrowing (Property and Casualty Companies and Marine Companies) Regulations
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Borrowing (Property and Casualty Companies and Marine Companies) Regulations Règlement sur les emprunts des sociétés d assurances multirisques et des sociétés d assurance
Plus en détailBILL C-452 PROJET DE LOI C-452 C-452 C-452 HOUSE OF COMMONS OF CANADA CHAMBRE DES COMMUNES DU CANADA
C-452 C-452 First Session, Forty-first Parliament, Première session, quarante et unième législature, HOUSE OF COMMONS OF CANADA CHAMBRE DES COMMUNES DU CANADA BILL C-452 PROJET DE LOI C-452 An Act to amend
Plus en détailOrdonnance sur le paiement à un enfant ou à une personne qui n est pas saine d esprit. Infant or Person of Unsound Mind Payment Order CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Infant or Person of Unsound Mind Payment Order Ordonnance sur le paiement à un enfant ou à une personne qui n est pas saine d esprit C.R.C., c. 1600 C.R.C., ch. 1600 Current
Plus en détailCONTINUING CONSOLIDATION OF STATUTES ACT LOI SUR LA CODIFICATION PERMANENTE DES LOIS. 1 In this Act,
CONTINUING CONSOLIDATION OF STATUTES ACT LOI SUR LA CODIFICATION PERMANENTE DES LOIS Definitions 1 In this Act, Chief Legislative Counsel means that member of the public service appointed to this position
Plus en détailPROJET DE LOI. An Act to Amend the Employment Standards Act. Loi modifiant la Loi sur les normes d emploi
2nd Session, 57th Legislature New Brunswick 60-61 Elizabeth II, 2011-2012 2 e session, 57 e législature Nouveau-Brunswick 60-61 Elizabeth II, 2011-2012 BILL PROJET DE LOI 7 7 An Act to Amend the Employment
Plus en détailLOI SUR LE RÉGIME D ASSURANCE COLLECTIVE DE LA FONCTION PUBLIQUE PUBLIC SERVICE GROUP INSURANCE BENEFIT PLAN ACT
PUBLIC SERVICE GROUP INSURANCE BENEFIT PLAN ACT LOI SUR LE RÉGIME D ASSURANCE COLLECTIVE DE LA FONCTION PUBLIQUE Application of this Act 1(1) This Act applies to the following (a) persons employed by the
Plus en détailArchived Content. Contenu archivé
ARCHIVED - Archiving Content ARCHIVÉE - Contenu archivé Archived Content Contenu archivé Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject
Plus en détailCONFLICT OF LAWS (TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS) ACT LOI SUR LES CONFLITS DE LOIS (ACCIDENTS DE LA CIRCULATION) Définitions et interprétation.
CONFLICT OF LAWS (TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS) ACT Interpretation 1(1) In this Act, accident means an accident that involves one or more vehicles and is connected with traffic on a highway; «accident» highway means
Plus en détailCOUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 18 September 2008 (19.09) (OR. fr) 13156/08 LIMITE PI 53
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION Brussels, 18 September 2008 (19.09) (OR. fr) 13156/08 LIMITE PI 53 WORKING DOCUMENT from : Presidency to : delegations No prev. doc.: 12621/08 PI 44 Subject : Revised draft
Plus en détailPRACTICE DIRECTION ON THE LENGTH OF BRIEFS AND MOTIONS ON APPEAL
Tribunal pénal international pour le Rwanda International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda PRACTICE DIRECTION ON THE LENGTH OF BRIEFS AND MOTIONS ON APPEAL INTRODUCTION In accordance with Rule 107bis of the
Plus en détailBill 69 Projet de loi 69
1ST SESSION, 41ST LEGISLATURE, ONTARIO 64 ELIZABETH II, 2015 1 re SESSION, 41 e LÉGISLATURE, ONTARIO 64 ELIZABETH II, 2015 Bill 69 Projet de loi 69 An Act to amend the Business Corporations Act and the
Plus en détailP R E T S P R E F E R E N T I E L S E T S U B V E N T I O N S D I N T E R Ê T S
P R E T S P R E F E R E N T I E L S E T S U B V E N T I O N S D I N T E R Ê T S Il est courant pour les employeurs d octroyer à leurs employés des prêts préférentiels ou des subventions d intérêts. L économie
Plus en détailLoi sur la remise de certaines dettes liées à l aide publique au développement. Forgiveness of Certain Official Development Assistance Debts Act
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Forgiveness of Certain Official Development Assistance Debts Act Loi sur la remise de certaines dettes liées à l aide publique au développement S.C. 1987, c. 27 L.C. 1987,
Plus en détaildonor which means an individual person who makes a charitable contribution to The Playhouse or one of its Clients;
THE FREDERICTON PLAYHOUSE INC. PRIVACY POLICY Commitment to Respecting Privacy of Information The Fredericton Playhouse Inc. ( The Playhouse ) is committed to protecting the privacy of information about
Plus en détailNORME INTERNATIONALE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD. Dispositifs à semiconducteurs Dispositifs discrets. Semiconductor devices Discrete devices
NORME INTERNATIONALE INTERNATIONAL STANDARD CEI IEC 747-6-3 QC 750113 Première édition First edition 1993-11 Dispositifs à semiconducteurs Dispositifs discrets Partie 6: Thyristors Section trois Spécification
Plus en détailImproving the breakdown of the Central Credit Register data by category of enterprises
Improving the breakdown of the Central Credit Register data by category of enterprises Workshop on Integrated management of micro-databases Deepening business intelligence within central banks statistical
Plus en détailCALCUL DE LA CONTRIBUTION - FONDS VERT Budget 2008/2009
Société en commandite Gaz Métro CALCUL DE LA CONTRIBUTION - FONDS VERT Budget 2008/2009 Taux de la contribution au Fonds vert au 1 er janvier 2009 Description Volume Coûts Taux 10³m³ 000 $ /m³ (1) (2)
Plus en détailAppointment or Deployment of Alternates Regulations. Règlement sur la nomination ou la mutation de remplaçants CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Appointment or Deployment of Alternates Regulations Règlement sur la nomination ou la mutation de remplaçants SOR/2012-83 DORS/2012-83 Current to August 30, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailNouveautés printemps 2013
» English Se désinscrire de la liste Nouveautés printemps 2013 19 mars 2013 Dans ce Flash Info, vous trouverez une description des nouveautés et mises à jour des produits La Capitale pour le printemps
Plus en détailREVISION DE LA DIRECTIVE ABUS DE MARCHE
REVISION DE LA DIRECTIVE ABUS DE MARCHE Principaux changements attendus 1 Le contexte La directive Abus de marché a huit ans (2003) Régimes de sanctions disparates dans l Union Harmonisation nécessaire
Plus en détailGeneral Import Permit No. 13 Beef and Veal for Personal Use. Licence générale d importation n O 13 bœuf et veau pour usage personnel CONSOLIDATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION General Import Permit No. 13 Beef and Veal for Personal Use Licence générale d importation n O 13 bœuf et veau pour usage personnel SOR/95-43 DORS/95-43 Current to June
Plus en détailFORMULAIRE D OUVERTURE DE COMPTE ENTREPRISE
FORMULAIRE D OUVERTURE DE COMPTE ENTREPRISE LISTE DE VERIFICATION Pour éviter tous retards dans le traitement de votre application pour l ouverture d un compte avec Oxford Markets ( OM, l Entreprise )
Plus en détailLOI SUR LE PROGRAMME DE TRAVAUX COMPENSATOIRES L.R.T.N.-O. 1988, ch. F-5. FINE OPTION ACT R.S.N.W.T. 1988,c.F-5
FINE OPTION ACT R.S.N.W.T. 1988,c.F-5 LOI SUR LE PROGRAMME DE TRAVAUX COMPENSATOIRES L.R.T.N.-O. 1988, ch. F-5 INCLUDING AMENDMENTS MADE BY S.N.W.T. 1997,c.3 S.N.W.T. 2003,c.31 In force April 1, 2004;
Plus en détailRèglement sur les baux visés à la Loi no 1 de 1977 portant affectation de crédits. Appropriation Act No. 1, 1977, Leasing Regulations CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Appropriation Act No. 1, 1977, Leasing Regulations Règlement sur les baux visés à la Loi no 1 de 1977 portant affectation de crédits C.R.C., c. 320 C.R.C., ch. 320 Current
Plus en détailIPSAS 32 «Service concession arrangements» (SCA) Marie-Pierre Cordier Baudouin Griton, IPSAS Board
IPSAS 32 «Service concession arrangements» (SCA) Marie-Pierre Cordier Baudouin Griton, IPSAS Board 1 L élaboration de la norme IPSAS 32 Objectif : traitement comptable des «service concession arrangements»
Plus en détailOrder Binding Certain Agents of Her Majesty for the Purposes of Part 1 of the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Order Binding Certain Agents of Her Majesty for the Purposes of Part 1 of the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act Décret liant certains mandataires
Plus en détailL'Offre sera ouverte pendant 18 jours de bourse, à un prix par action de 152,30 EUR. BPCE International et Outre-Mer
CORPORATE EVENT NOTICE: Offre publique d'achat simplifiée REUNION(BANQUE DE LA) PLACE: Paris AVIS N : PAR_20150402_02663_EUR DATE: 02/04/2015 MARCHE: EURONEXT PARIS Le 02/04/2015, l'autorité des marchés
Plus en détailC H A P T E R 4 C H A P I T R E 4. (Assented to June 16, 2011) (Date de sanction : 16 juin 2011)
C H A P T E R 4 C H A P I T R E 4 THE PRESCRIPTION DRUGS COST ASSISTANCE AMENDMENT ACT (PRESCRIPTION DRUG MONITORING AND MISCELLANEOUS AMENDMENTS) LOI MODIFIANT LA LOI SUR L'AIDE À L'ACHAT DE MÉDICAMENTS
Plus en détailNordion Europe S.A. Incorporation Authorization Order. Décret autorisant la constitution de Nordion Europe S.A. CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Nordion Europe S.A. Incorporation Authorization Order Décret autorisant la constitution de Nordion Europe S.A. SOR/90-162 DORS/90-162 Current to June 9, 2015 À jour au
Plus en détailOrder Varying Telecom Decision CRTC 2005-28. Décret modifiant la décision Télécom CRTC 2005-28 CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Order Varying Telecom Decision CRTC 2005-28 Décret modifiant la décision Télécom CRTC 2005-28 SOR/2006-288 DORS/2006-288 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour au 4 août 2015
Plus en détailthat the child(ren) was/were in need of protection under Part III of the Child and Family Services Act, and the court made an order on
ONTARIO Court File Number at (Name of court) Court office address Applicant(s) (In most cases, the applicant will be a children s aid society.) Full legal name & address for service street & number, municipality,
Plus en détailStatement of the European Council of Medical Orders on telemedicine
Statement of the European Council of Medical Orders on telemedicine The CEOM statement on telemedicine was formally adopted by its participating organisations during the CEOM plenary meeting held in Bari
Plus en détailMarché britannique : la nouvelle loi «Retail Distribution Review» préfigure-t-elle ce qui se passera sur d autres marchés?
Marché britannique : la nouvelle loi «Retail Distribution Review» préfigure-t-elle ce qui se passera sur d autres marchés? Philip Woolfson, Avocat, Paris et Bruxelles, établi à Bruxelles Steptoe & Johnson
Plus en détailMultiple issuers. La cotation des actions ROBECO ci-dessous est suspendue sur EURONEXT PARIS dans les conditions suivantes :
CORPORATE EVENT NOTICE: Suspension de cotation Multiple issuers PLACE: Paris AVIS N : PAR_20141002_07393_EUR DATE: 02/10/2014 MARCHE: EURONEXT PARIS La cotation des fonds mentionnés ci-dessous sera suspendue
Plus en détailAUDIT COMMITTEE: TERMS OF REFERENCE
AUDIT COMMITTEE: TERMS OF REFERENCE PURPOSE The Audit Committee (the Committee), assists the Board of Trustees to fulfill its oversight responsibilities to the Crown, as shareholder, for the following
Plus en détailPIB : Définition : mesure de l activité économique réalisée à l échelle d une nation sur une période donnée.
PIB : Définition : mesure de l activité économique réalisée à l échelle d une nation sur une période donnée. Il y a trois approches possibles du produit intérieur brut : Optique de la production Optique
Plus en détailBILL 203 PROJET DE LOI 203
Bill 203 Private Member's Bill Projet de loi 203 Projet de loi d'un député 4 th Session, 40 th Legislature, Manitoba, 63 Elizabeth II, 2014 4 e session, 40 e législature, Manitoba, 63 Elizabeth II, 2014
Plus en détailFCM 2015 ANNUAL CONFERENCE AND TRADE SHOW Terms and Conditions for Delegates and Companions Shaw Convention Centre, Edmonton, AB June 5 8, 2015
FCM 2015 ANNUAL CONFERENCE AND TRADE SHOW Terms and Conditions for Delegates and Companions Shaw Convention Centre, Edmonton, AB June 5 8, 2015 Early-bird registration Early-bird registration ends April
Plus en détailAnnexe IV: Politique d Exécution dans le Meilleur Intérêt du Client. Appendix IV: Summary of the Policy to Act in the Best Interest of the Client
Appendix IV: Summary of the Policy to Act in the Best Interest of the Client IV. Summary of the Policy to Act in the Best Interest of the Client Annexe IV: Politique d Exécution dans le Meilleur Intérêt
Plus en détailRailway Operating Certificate Regulations. Règlement sur les certificats d exploitation de chemin de fer CODIFICATION CONSOLIDATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Railway Operating Certificate Regulations Règlement sur les certificats d exploitation de chemin de fer SOR/2014-258 DORS/2014-258 Current to September 10, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailCONSOLIDATION OF ABORIGINAL CUSTOM ADOPTION RECOGNITION ACT S.N.W.T. 1994,c.26 In force September 30, 1995; SI-009-95
CONSOLIDATION OF ABORIGINAL CUSTOM ADOPTION RECOGNITION ACT S.N.W.T. 1994,c.26 In force September 30, 1995; SI-009-95 CODIFICATION ADMINISTRATIVE DE LA LOI SUR LA RECONNAISSANCE DE L ADOPTION SELON LES
Plus en détailConfirmation du titulaire de la carte en cas de contestation de transaction(s) Cardholder s Certification of Disputed Transactions
Confirmation du titulaire de la carte en cas de contestation de transaction(s) Cardholder s Certification of Disputed Transactions Informations personnelles Nom/Prénom Name / Firstname Numéro de la carte
Plus en détailPractice Direction. Class Proceedings
Effective Date: 2010/07/01 Number: PD - 5 Title: Practice Direction Class Proceedings Summary: This Practice Direction describes the procedure for requesting the assignment of a judge in a proceeding under
Plus en détailSmall Businesses support Senator Ringuette s bill to limit credit card acceptance fees
For Immediate Release October 10, 2014 Small Businesses support Senator Ringuette s bill to limit credit card acceptance fees The Senate Standing Committee on Banking, Trade, and Commerce resumed hearings
Plus en détailApplication Form/ Formulaire de demande
Application Form/ Formulaire de demande Ecosystem Approaches to Health: Summer Workshop and Field school Approches écosystémiques de la santé: Atelier intensif et stage d été Please submit your application
Plus en détailOttawa,, 2009 Ottawa, le 2009
Avis est donné que la gouverneure en conseil, en vertu des articles 479 à 485 a, 488 b et 1021 c de la Loi sur les sociétés d assurances d, se propose de prendre le Règlement modifiant le Règlement sur
Plus en détailETABLISSEMENT D ENSEIGNEMENT OU ORGANISME DE FORMATION / UNIVERSITY OR COLLEGE:
8. Tripartite internship agreement La présente convention a pour objet de définir les conditions dans lesquelles le stagiaire ci-après nommé sera accueilli dans l entreprise. This contract defines the
Plus en détailLE FORMAT DES RAPPORTS DU PERSONNEL DES COMMISSIONS DE DISTRICT D AMENAGEMENT FORMAT OF DISTRICT PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS
FORMAT OF DISTRICT PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORTS LE FORMAT DES RAPPORTS DU PERSONNEL DES COMMISSIONS DE DISTRICT D AMENAGEMENT A Guideline on the Format of District Planning Commission Staff Reports
Plus en détailiqtool - Outil e-learning innovateur pour enseigner la Gestion de Qualité au niveau BAC+2
iqtool - Outil e-learning innovateur pour enseigner la Gestion de Qualité au niveau BAC+2 134712-LLP-2007-HU-LEONARDO-LMP 1 Information sur le projet iqtool - Outil e-learning innovateur pour enseigner
Plus en détailAvis certifiant que des pays accordent les avantages du droit d auteur. Certification of Countries Granting Equal Copyright Protection Notice
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Certification of Countries Granting Equal Copyright Protection Notice Avis certifiant que des pays accordent les avantages du droit d auteur C.R.C., c. 41 C.R.C., ch.
Plus en détailUn système KYC robuste et sa valeur ajoutée commerciale
MY JOURNEY BEGAN AT 19, WHEN I LANDED IN THE COLDEST PLACE I D EVER EXPERIENCED. MAJID AL-NASSAR BUSINESS OWNER AND PROPERTY INVESTOR. EVERY JOURNEY IS UNIQUE. Un système KYC robuste et sa valeur ajoutée
Plus en détailPanorama des bonnes pratiques de reporting «corruption»
Panorama des bonnes pratiques de reporting «corruption» L inventaire ci-après, présente des bonnes pratiques des entreprises du CAC40 ainsi que des bonnes pratiques étrangères et, est organisé dans l ordre
Plus en détailBNP Paribas Personal Finance
BNP Paribas Personal Finance Financially fragile loan holder prevention program CUSTOMERS IN DIFFICULTY: QUICKER IDENTIFICATION MEANS BETTER SUPPORT Brussels, December 12th 2014 Why BNPP PF has developed
Plus en détailCONVENTION DE STAGE TYPE STANDART TRAINING CONTRACT
CONVENTION DE STAGE TYPE STANDART TRAINING CONTRACT La présente convention a pour objet de définir les conditions dans lesquelles le stagiaire ci-après nommé sera accueilli dans l entreprise. This contract
Plus en détailMon Service Public - Case study and Mapping to SAML/Liberty specifications. Gaël Gourmelen - France Telecom 23/04/2007
Mon Service Public - Case study and Mapping to SAML/Liberty specifications Gaël Gourmelen - France Telecom 23/04/2007 Agenda Brief presentation of the "Mon Service Public" project (main features) Detailed
Plus en détailMaterial Banking Group Percentage Regulations. Règlement fixant le pourcentage (groupe bancaire important) CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Material Banking Group Percentage Regulations Règlement fixant le pourcentage (groupe bancaire important) SOR/2008-163 DORS/2008-163 Current to August 30, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailScénarios économiques en assurance
Motivation et plan du cours Galea & Associés ISFA - Université Lyon 1 ptherond@galea-associes.eu pierre@therond.fr 18 octobre 2013 Motivation Les nouveaux référentiels prudentiel et d'information nancière
Plus en détailPAR_20141217_09543_EUR DATE: 17/12/2014. Suite à l'avis PAR_20141119_08654_EUR
CORPORATE EVENT NOTICE: Emission avec maintien du droit préférentiel de souscription, d obligations convertibles en actions ordinaires nouvelles assorties de bons de souscription d action («OCABSA») -
Plus en détailEU- Luxemburg- WHO Universal Health Coverage Partnership:
EU- Luxemburg- WHO Universal Health Coverage Partnership: Supporting policy dialogue on national health policies, strategies and plans and universal coverage Year 2 Report Jan. 2013 - - Dec. 2013 [Version
Plus en détailResident Canadian (Insurance Companies) Regulations. Règlement sur les résidents canadiens (sociétés d assurances) CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Resident Canadian (Insurance Companies) Regulations Règlement sur les résidents canadiens (sociétés d assurances) SOR/92-284 DORS/92-284 Current to August 4, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailde stabilisation financière
CHAPTER 108 CHAPITRE 108 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Act Loi sur le Fonds de stabilisation financière Table of Contents 1 Definitions eligible securities valeurs admissibles Fund Fonds Minister ministre
Plus en détailTABLE DES MATIÈRES page Présentation... v Avant-propos... vii Table de la jurisprudence... xvii Table des abréviations... xxxi
TABLE DES MATIÈRES Présentation........................ v Avant-propos...................... vii Table de la jurisprudence............ xvii Table des abréviations............. xxxi LOI SUR LA PROTECTION
Plus en détailShort-term Pooled Investment Fund Regulations. Règlement sur le fonds commun de placement à court terme CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Short-term Pooled Investment Fund Regulations Règlement sur le fonds commun de placement à court terme SOR/2006-245 DORS/2006-245 Current to September 27, 2015 À jour
Plus en détailCONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION. Current to August 30, 2015 À jour au 30 août 2015
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Order Transferring to the Department of Supply and Services the Control and Supervision of the Government Telecommunications Agency and the Translation Bureau and Transferring
Plus en détailPrepaid Payment Products Regulations. Règlement sur les produits de paiement prépayés CODIFICATION CONSOLIDATION. Current to September 10, 2015
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Prepaid Payment Products Regulations Règlement sur les produits de paiement prépayés SOR/2013-209 DORS/2013-209 Current to September 10, 2015 À jour au 10 septembre 2015
Plus en détailShips Elevator Regulations. Règlement sur les ascenseurs de navires CODIFICATION CONSOLIDATION. C.R.C., c. 1482 C.R.C., ch. 1482
CANADA CONSOLIDATION CODIFICATION Ships Elevator Regulations Règlement sur les ascenseurs de navires C.R.C., c. 1482 C.R.C., ch. 1482 Current to September 10, 2015 À jour au 10 septembre 2015 Last amended
Plus en détailEnglish Q&A #1 Braille Services Requirement PPTC 144918. Q1. Would you like our proposal to be shipped or do you prefer an electronic submission?
English Q&A #1 Braille Services Requirement PPTC 144918 Q1. Would you like our proposal to be shipped or do you prefer an electronic submission? A1. Passport Canada requests that bidders provide their
Plus en détailBILL C-556 PROJET DE LOI C-556 C-556 C-556 CHAMBRE DES COMMUNES DU CANADA HOUSE OF COMMONS OF CANADA
C-6 C-6 Second Session, Forty-first Parliament, Deuxième session, quarante et unième législature, HOUSE OF COMMONS OF CANADA CHAMBRE DES COMMUNES DU CANADA BILL C-6 PROJET DE LOI C-6 An Act to amend the
Plus en détail